Is it better to take the IELTS test with IDP than with British Council? Or should it be the other way around? This question keeps haunting a number of test takers in Asian countries where both the British Council and IDP conduct the exam.
The discussion is going hilariously viral. Unaware of the reality, many people preparing for the test these days spend a lot of time comparing and contrasting IDP and the British Council instead of practicing for the test. The official IELTS website and the respective websites of the British Council and IDP clearly say that IELTS is jointly owned by the British Council, IDP: IELTS Australia and the University of Cambridge ESOL Examinations. All official literature carry the stamps of all the three bodies – Cambridge IELTS books, promotional materials and the official answer/transfer sheets used in the real test, to name but a few. What’s more, the TRF (Test Report Form) also comes with the official stamps of the three organizations involved in the test irrespective of whether the test is conducted by the British Council or IDP.
So what’s all the fuss about? Having been an IELTS trainer for many years, I am often asked this question. So, I dug a little deeper into the matter. ELTS (no, not a spelling mistake; it was the name back then, which stood for English Language Testing Services) was launched in 1980 by Cambridge English Language Assessment (also known as UCLES) and the British Council. Soon the test started to receive worldwide popularity and acceptance, both by test takers and various recognizing bodies. It resulted in an increasing number of people sitting the exam year after year. With the increasing demand came a bundle of practical difficulties administering the test. As a result, the ELTS Revision Project was set up. The test content was revamped to ensure international participation. It was done in collaboration with the International Development Program of Australian Universities and Colleges (IDP), now known as IDP: IELTS Australia. This collaboration facilitated the process of administering the test worldwide and partnership is reflected in its new name: the International English Language Testing System (IELTS).
So, it is clear that the entry of IDP: IELTS Australia was to promote international participation and for the smooth administration of the test worldwide together with the British Council. Not to make the test simpler or more difficult – contrary to popular conflicting beliefs! So, it boils down to this: The University of Cambridge’s UCLES (University of Cambridge Local Examination Syndicate) constructs the exam material. It is a multi-stage process that includes commissioning, editing, pretesting, analysis and banking of the material and standards fixing. Well, what is the role of the British Council and IDP then? They conduct the test in different countries throughout the year. Managing test centers, scheduling test dates, maintaining quality, processing applications, etc. are some of their responsibilities. Remember: neither the British Council nor the IDP constructs test material, and hence it’s foolish to think one is more difficult than the other. If you are still doubtful but lucky, try to find two candidates who sat the test on the same day in your country – one with the British Council and the other with the IDP. Ask them what the reading passages or the writing tasks were, for example. They will be the same.
The complaining folks
Just google ‘British Council or IDP IELTS easy.' You will see many links to seriously funny discussions on this matter. Most people who comment and share their experience are IELTS test re-takers. Some had a better experience with the British Council. They abuse the IDP test. The supporters of IDP mud-sling the British Council. The third group (who couldn’t make it with either) curses both of them. It’s quite natural that a good number of candidates score better when they repeat a test but it doesn’t prove that their first testing body was difficult. It only shows that they practiced a little more, gained a pinch more confidence by facing the real thing once, and got a better band score the second time. That’s it.
Another interesting thing about most commenters is that many of them seem to be self-styled examiners. They write their scores and argue that they deserve more but, unfortunately, the language of their comments itself doesn’t attest to their claims.
Is the IELTS test easier in some cities than in others?
Not at all. Incidentally, this question is out of the scope of this article yet worth answering for the benefit of test takers. The exam is an international standardized test with the same difficulty level across the world. It doesn’t matter whether you take the test in Denmark or Delhi; Peru or Peshawar; north or south. Period! Many in South Asia think certain cities are easier than big ones for weird reasons. Here is an interesting example: Punjab is an Indian state with the highest number of test-takers in the sub-continent. Many candidates from Amritsar (a city in Punjab) believe that the exam in Jalandhar (another nearby city) is easier, while those in Jalandhar go to Amritsar thinking the opposite. When asked why they believe that, they could not say anything more than ‘my friends told me.' Is that all? After trying both centers in quick succession (instead of working on their English), many Punjabi brethren often wonder, is there a much easier third option? Just to add to the confusion, even some IELTS trainers misinform their students by advising them to prefer a particular test city to other. Believe me, choosing a test center over another one in search of an easy version of IELTS is utter stupidity.
To sum up...
IELTS, the world's most popular high-stakes English-language exam for study, work and migration is designed to assess how well you understand, read, write and speak English. Learn as much English as possible and take the test. You can’t fail. Both the British Council and IDP IELTS examiners who give you the test are highly trained ELT professionals. Brush up on your language skills, prepare for the test and take it confidently. Success will not elude you.
santhosh on May 27, 2019:
when i didn't made a good score in idp IELTS then i paid the fees for british council but iam finding it difficult with BC coz in listening matching the idp will tell the matching in orderly manner when it comes to BC the conversation for matchings will be from middle or last what ever they like and when comes to reading looks little bit difficult this is my personal experience
Carrui77 on January 08, 2019:
Both are the same. It’s just the difference between two colleges of same university. My friend is also taking ielts coaching in Chandigarh since a couple of months. And now all set to give the exam next week. She took separate speaking classes and grammar sessions as well. Is now quite confident to attain her desired score.
Reethu on July 08, 2017:
I find difficulty with idp listening test
When compared to British council
NIvethitha on May 13, 2017:
Hi, I planned to register IELTS on june 1 st week. Can anyone suggest me IDP or British council which one is better?
Amanpreet Kaur on May 27, 2016:
It is really helpful, Thankyou once again for this wonderful and informative text.
Pulkit on May 24, 2016:
ha ha ha. This happens only in India. Indians always think of shortcuts. Instead of improving their English, they keep comparing IDP and BC and keep taking the test again and again.
Recommended for You
Sunil Joshi on April 25, 2016:
Oh. That's an awesome piece of information, writer. Thanks
jackchubby (author) on March 22, 2016:
Thank you Muddassir. Let's try our best to spread the truth by the way.
Muddassir on March 22, 2016:
informative, well-written article and is of worth to share.
P.S: it is not only difficult to convince Indian's but Pakistani's too ;-)
Neeraj Bhandari on March 12, 2016:
Thanks for help. I was confused very much
jackchubby (author) on March 03, 2016:
Thank you Money, Pankaj, Baiju, Ankush, Manoj and Sham. Glad to know that you found this hub useful.
Sham Manali on March 02, 2016:
Thanks a ton for this kind information. I was confused about these questions. You helped me a lot. But my many friends have different different opinions about it, thanks anyway.
Manoj S on February 21, 2016:
Thanks a lot. This is my opinion too but a lot of people do not agree unfortunately. Good work. Keep it up,
Ankush Amritsar on February 15, 2016:
Amritsar IELTS is easier than Jalandhar. Everybody know it. You don't know anything. What you mean
Unknown on February 03, 2016:
IDP is private company so theyare more easy and little bit helpful but bc is British government company so strict people. My experience. I gave ielts test 5 times.
Pankaj Rampal on February 03, 2016:
Thats an awesone piece of info dude. I have the same opiniin and personal experience but difficult to convince Indians... :(
baiju Yesudas on February 02, 2016:
But in north Indian test centers it is more easy than south India because in south India they ask more difficult questions as English standard is very high in South. Many of my friends are the proof of it. After scoring low in the test in Kerala, they repeated in Ambala (Haryana) and improved their score by 1 band. What does it prove?
Money Singh on February 02, 2016:
Thanks a lot. It is nice to know about why there are two IELTS bodies to conduct the exam in my country. Very informative. I was worried that I filled IELTS with IDP and on 13 Feb is my exam in Bhatinda (Punjab). Somebody told me I should have opted IDP. Now I feel relaxed. Thanks a lot.