I have been a mental health professional for over 20 years. I provide case management services for people with developmental disabilities.
The job market has become much more competitive in the last few years. As companies cut back on labor to stay in business, education has become extremely important for employees who want to be more competitive in their current positions or want to transition into a new career. The level of competition for good jobs has made obtaining a certification or degree an absolute necessity. More people are returning to school than ever before. Many are choosing to obtain degrees online while others are returning to the campus to further their education. So which option is better? Let’s explore the pros and cons of both.
Trends in Education
Education has become one of the fastest growing “businesses” in recent years. It seems like there is a new commercial every week for a new online university, technical, or school of business. Online education has become more popular in today’s fast paced society. Online courses allow students to take courses from different states and even from different countries. I personally received my MPA from Troy University (Alabama) from the comfort of my home in Virginia. Some schools offer in-class courses, online courses, or hybrid courses. Hybrid courses are both in-class and online. These courses often have online classes one week and in-class sessions the next week. Some schools offer hybrid programs which include a mix of in-class courses, online courses, and hybrid classes. More Traditional schools or so called “brick and mortar” institutions are offering more online courses in response to the surge of online universities. I was a little resistant to online courses. However, my job and family responsibilities made it a necessity to take online courses and it turned out to be the best option for me.
The Case for Traditional Education
The traditional college experience consists of attending classes in person on a campus. Younger students who are attending college for the first time could benefit from the traditional learning environment. Younger students may need more guidance and more direct contact with professors and academic advisors. Traditional classes may also be a better fit for students with limited resources and limited computer access. If you’re living on campus, it only makes sense to take classes on campus.
For the more “mature” student, the traditional educational setting in the classroom may be a more comfortable fit. This option may also be better if the student is returning to school for the first time in many years. Although this is not always the case, older students tend to be a little less tech savvy and might prefer a more traditional setting.
Students who value the campus experience may also find the traditional campus atmosphere more desirable than just an online experience. There are more opportunities to engage in student activities such as fraternities/sororities as well as concerts and sporting events that typically occur on campus.
The classroom setting is also the most appropriate setting for technical or trade schools. Education on campus is also needed in professions that specifically require “hands on” training in laboratories, clinics, and shops. These schools consist of but are not limited to the following areas of study:
Computer Science/ Engineering
Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning Technician (HVAC)
Nursing/ Medical Professions
Chef/ Food Service
The Case for Online Education
Online education, also referred to as distance learning involves taking courses over the internet as opposed to in the classroom setting. Online education has become more popular in recent years. This popularity is largely due to the flexibility and convenience that an online educational experience provides. Online education provides an opportunity to take classes from the convenience of home. In addition, online education provides more flexibility by allowing students to work at their own pace without the confines of a strict class schedule.
Online classes tend to be more beneficial for students who work full-time and have additional family responsibilities. Online course assignments can be completed at work (don’t tell my boss), home, or anywhere you can carry your laptop. This form of learning makes it ideal for students on the go.
In addition to flexibly and convenience, online courses can also be more cost effective. Classes are taken online so there is no need to drive to class. This saves gas as well as additional wear and tear on your vehicle. Each school is different so you may be required to take certain tests in person at “proctor” sites. These sites are approved by the university and work directly with the school to ensure that students are taking tests as instructed (i.e., no books, notes, etc).
Online schools are also ideal for students in the military or have jobs that require frequent travel. Courses can be taken from anywhere in the world. When I was at Troy University, I took classes with students in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. It was really interesting to interact with students from all over the country. I have listed a few pros and cons of online education and the traditional campus experience.
Advantages of Online Education
1. More flexibility for students who work full-time
2. The ability to complete assignments at times when it is most convenient
3. The ability to obtain a degree from a school in another state without moving
4. This form of education is ideal for military students
5. Less Travel
Disadvantages of Online Education
1. Less direct contact with students and professors
2. Limited opportunities for student and campus activities
3. Subject to “technical difficulties” and software crashes
Advantages of Traditional Education
1. Direct contact with teachers, students, and advisors
2. More access to campus activities
3. More suitable for hands on training
Disadvantages of Traditional Education
1. Less flexibility in class scheduling
2. Less cost effective
3. More travel to and from class
Despite the surge in online universities, I believe there is more than enough room for both options. The key is to find the best fit for your personal needs. Education has proven to be the key to success and it really doesn’t matter which method you choose. There is nothing like the campus experience. However, there is no disputing the flexibility and convenience of distance learning.
© 2013 Martin D Gardner
Alice King on August 29, 2020:
I like the personal touch of classroom learning, and find that some students really need that one on one! However, online learning is making major strides with the current economic and Covid situation. It certainly allows the student more flexibility, more economical in a number of ways also and teachers are becoming more creative and technologically savvy to make the classes more interesting and challenging.
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on July 28, 2020:
Thanks for the feedback Michael. I'm not sure what you mean by "Worship and "Hebrew"
Michael Alan Whorley on July 28, 2020:
In the Age of Covid-19, and at my age (67) online learning is my only option. Fortunately, I have completed most of my CRE/CLP courses successfully online, and am completely comfortable with this format.
On another note, when visiting the section that had the examples "Worship" and "Hebrew", I listened to all of "Worship", but "Hebrew" generated an error message making it impossible to complete the section, which remains "unchecked". I look forward to your response. Thank you.
Maria on August 22, 2019:
Hi, I would like to defend the online experience. It's more than convenience, flexibility the main reason why I prefer online learning is because all of your lectures, past test. chapters are at your fingertips and you can review them as often as you like. In addition to you can take notes and repeat the information if you need to. The online discussion forum is another great quality. If someone of your class mates has information on their discussion forum you can now review it as often as you like. It is a great option, just my opinion. Thank you.
Keninel on April 23, 2019:
Great hub . ty !
Edward G Gordon from Northern Ireland on April 04, 2019:
I'm a big fan of online/distance learning. I find it easier. That's a personal opinion of course.
The one positive I have about bricks and mortar learning is the connection that often develops between teachers and their students. This can often speed up the learning process when a student hits a wall and they need a hand to get over it.
On that point I definitely agree with you.
Scott Hanna on September 26, 2018:
I think I prefer online learning. First time. Only time will tell!!!
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on August 30, 2018:
I haven't been up here in a while but I appreciate the comments and feedback. Thanks.
Cheryl Collins on August 25, 2018:
Online learning is something new for me to participate in. I look forward to this new adventure.
Cindy Kneiss on August 06, 2018:
On-line is new to me, but wish it had been more available back in 70's and 80's.
David Watts on August 04, 2018:
Nothing new, we are all looking for what can fit into our schedule, our pocketbook and correctly gets the job done. With good value. Blessings.
belicia okwuonyechie on May 09, 2018:
I love this article it is amazing and so help ful
Ray Bennet on January 15, 2018:
Remote courses have existed for a good 40 years or so with the Open University. The big difference now with the Internet is that the communication can be instantly two way and in real time.
So yes, online courses are definitely the future. Maybe with the pressure on costs and the high fees being charged universities will be forced to become "summer schools" for their undergraduates, with most of the teaching taking place online and remote.
Memez Virus on May 04, 2017:
joe on March 12, 2017:
hi. i like this article. very helpful
Chichi on February 23, 2017:
For me I prefer online cos more than half of my day is spent online. Almost all my daily engagements are online. On campus couldn't have been better for me.
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on January 21, 2017:
Thanks for the positive feedback. Both options provide great benefits. I'm noticing the hybrid classes are becoming more popular as well.
Jack Berghorst on January 20, 2017:
good article. I'm happy that I have been able to do both. Campus living was great, but at this stage in my life, online is perfect.
Kris Maldarelli on January 10, 2017:
As an instructor both online and onsite, I prefer teaching onsite, but love the flexibility of online learning as a student.
Leesa Johnson on January 07, 2017:
Nice information. In competitive days online education plays an important role in human life because they can learn many skills online from experts. A traditional method of teaching also important because students can directly connect with teachers, students, and advisors.
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on October 01, 2015:
Good point. Online classes come in handy when it's 3-4 inches of snow on the ground. Thanks for stopping by.
Debra Hargrove from North Carolina on September 30, 2015:
Your hub is very useful. Now that the weather is getting colder it's a good time to look into something meaningful to do indoors while waiting for spring.
robertkbrown on July 16, 2015:
It was nice reading your article :) I have been planning on getting a California contractors license ( http://www.freedombusinessschool.com/scripts/prodL... ) . The thing is , I have been busy with work and distance education; and online learning is the only option I have. I was confused with which option should I choose. Your article has helped me to reach a final decision.
Maharshi Rudra from India on June 04, 2015:
On Campus learning... it's like main pillar of society.
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on March 29, 2015:
Rakim congrats on your graduation and thanks for the comments. Online education is definitely on the rise in our fast paced paced society.
Rakim Cheeks on March 28, 2015:
Great hub! I recently graduated from college last December! And I have to say I got a chance to experience a traditional education and a online education. To be Frank, both were great assets for me. However, if I had to choose one, I'd probably go with the online education because I'll be able to commuicate with most of my classmates, and engage in online discussions. Not to mention, more online courses are increasing in today's society. Again, outstanding Hub Mr. Gardner
Emma Emily on November 03, 2014:
Thanks a lot
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on October 29, 2014:
Dhimanreena thanks for stopping by and the kind comment.
Reena Dhiman on October 29, 2014:
Thanks for a great hub. Both education type have distinct benefits. Online education is cheap & easy as compare to traditional education. But some people want learning via online due to their job for which online education is best.
Shivani Tiwari on August 14, 2014:
online education is very good for those who are not bookworms and want to gain knowledge with creativity and intereset very flexible less time consuming
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on August 05, 2014:
Thanks for reading and commenting. I was a little nervous about online education but it ended up being the best choice once I became too busy to attend classes.
Best Online Schools from UK on August 05, 2014:
It is true as Melinda pointed out that online schooling requires more handwork, more reading plus self-discipline among others. But at the end of the day online schooling is worth it as per my experience.
Inspire, Motivate and Engage on May 19, 2014:
Really insightful, thank you for sharing. You raise some very interesting pros and cons for online versus traditional education. We have also written about the benefits of online education here 'tinyurl.com/benefitsofelearning'. I hope you find it as an interesting read.
Lisa on May 09, 2014:
Online education has many advantages like what you wrote in this article. However, not all education can be done online. For example, part of healthcare courses can be done online. But students must take clinical training to understand what they learned in a real life. I recently wrote an article about how to choose the right online sonography program, you may have interest in it: http://www.ultrasoundtechniciancenter.org/online-s...
Good feedback is welcome! Thanks for sharing.
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on January 08, 2014:
Thanks for the feedback FullofLoveSites. Melinda I agree discipline is the key especially for online courses.
Melinda Longoria MSM from Garland, Texas on January 08, 2014:
I obtained two of three of my degrees online. Quite a few of my professors stated during orientation that their online format was more difficult than traditional classes because they expected more of students who took online courses. Knowing the difference between the two, I would agree with this statement. I found that a lot more reading and self discipline is required for the online classes.
FullOfLoveSites from United States on January 08, 2014:
To me traditional education is better, but I also agree with the benefits of online education especially to those working students or stay-at-home parents who still aim to get a degree. Very helpful and interesting hub, thanks for posting. :)
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on November 01, 2013:
Thanks. I'm glad you found it helpful.
Salman Hussain on November 01, 2013:
Thanks for your valuable advise I definitely go with to get education through Online due to my job and family look after my job
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on September 13, 2013:
Thanks. Yes the personal connection is not the same when taking classes online.
TANJIM ARAFAT SAJIB from Bangladesh on September 12, 2013:
I prefer on campus education than online education. I think education is not about to learn or gather only the textbook knowledge. It’s about to communicate the others, discuss, group work etc. Online education means distance education. At present it significantly spread all over the world. It has some good result too. Many students doing well in the job sector who get knowledge form online. But I like campus education. It helps a student to build up his or her mental and physical strength besides textbook knowledge. Nice hub. Thanks.
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on September 02, 2013:
Thanks. I'm new as well and still learning.
Schoolmom24 from Oregon on September 02, 2013:
Great job with this hub. It's true, it really depends on the individual and what those needs\desires are. Today, my guess is that online degrees are a lot less expensive and quicker than attending a four year college! And so many have to pay student loans for years and years. Not sure if our kids could go to college without a scholarship...Anyway, you presented both sides well, voted up! I'm new here and hope you'll stop by! :)
Natya Sri on August 27, 2013:
thanks for the good information good luck to you
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on August 25, 2013:
Thanks and good luck to you.
sminut13 from singapore on August 25, 2013:
Thanks for sharing this informative hub. I agree with the earlier post in that doing online courses definitely need lots of self-discipline. I tried to do an online free course, just to improve something of myself and I'm just too lazy hehe But it's also partly due to the poor internet connection at my place. Hopefully, after my holiday, I can continue it where I stay and complete it. Thanks once again.
RoseP28 on August 24, 2013:
Excellent job on your comparison. I am almost finished with an online program myself and it can definitely be rewarding but certainly requires a great deal of self-discipline as mentioned. It is not for everyone but you can get hands-on experience depending on the program your school has. Although you do not have the face-to-face interaction, you still do have a lot of involvement with your professors and other students through discussion forums, online class projects, and weekly assignments depending on how each class is set up. I highly recommend them for people who are motivated enough to complete the program but are unable to attend traditional classes. Thank you for your great insight on options to get an education.
cozytown from Mechanicville, NY on August 24, 2013:
Great job. I have found that online education takes a great deal of self-discipline to complete the classes. The open-ended classes where you have to complete the work ... whenever are truly difficult. Stick with the ones with deadlines and more structure and things will be a lot easier.
Dora Weithers from The Caribbean on August 23, 2013:
Great job of comparing distance learning with traditional classes. I fully agree with your conclusion. Welcome to HubPages, and I'm honored to follow you.
Tre Griffey from Utah, USA on August 23, 2013:
I think that traditional education is better. I'm always so skeptical of doing classes online. I think that I won't learn what I need to and then I'll have problems on test or even in the future.
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on August 22, 2013:
Elizabeth Parker from Las Vegas, NV on August 21, 2013:
I actually love writing, so it didn't bother me too badly, (thankfully)!
Martin D Gardner (author) from Virginia Beach on August 21, 2013:
Thanks for your input and the welcome. I agree online courses are much harder than people think. I would much rather be in class instead of writing out everything to get credit for participation.
Elizabeth Parker from Las Vegas, NV on August 21, 2013:
Since I wanted to get my Bachelors when I was in my late thirties, I was too busy to attend school at a campus, so I chose University of Phoenix online. I loved it. I think there's a common misconception that online school is easier, however, in a way, it's just as hard, if not more difficult because there is a ton of writing involved versus in classroom participation, which I was never fond of! Great explanation in this hub. voted up and welcome to hubpages!
ignugent17 on August 21, 2013:
I think I will always like traditional education. We can do things online but I still need to be with people to discuss things face to face. :-)