Peter Conser: Tragedy and Triumph – A Tale of the Indian Territories

In the years following the terrible “Trail of Tears”, and before Oklahoma gained statehood, the Indian Territories remained wild and rugged.  In southeastern Oklahoma, in what was once the Choctaw Nation, there lived a man who would come to define what it meant to be victorious over an unforgiving frontier.  

Early Life of Young Peter Conser

It was in 1852 that Peter Coinson was born into an unhappy, mournful life.

Eagletown was still a relatively young town, but the place had all the promise of a big city. Peter’s father, a Swiss immigrant from the Canton of Bern, named T.X. Coinson, was drawn to the growing town like a moth to flame. After marrying a full blood Choctaw woman, it didn’t take long for T.X. to establish a trading business in the area.

It can be speculated that T.X. Coinson arrived in Eagletown during the "Golden Years" of Choctaw expansion. This period followed the end of the Indian relocations in Indian Territory. During this time, Choctaw Indians worked diligently to reestablish their social, economic, and political institutions, and were highly successful until the American Civil War interrupted this.

As was typical during those years, and especially after the Civil War, white businessmen would marry Indian women in order to obtain full citizenships rights within the tribe. This was important in the Indian Territory because only Indians were legally allowed to own land and operate a business. In many situations, these businessmen became highly successful while operating in Indian Territory. In other situations, the businessman simply ended up losing every penny they owned. It can only be speculated whether Peter's father left due to prosperity or due to famine; but nonetheless, he left when Peter was still a small boy.

Adeline, Peter’s mother, was left holding the ashes of a failed marriage. While she did her best to raise young Peter, it was still near impossible for a single mother to survive in those days. In 1857, when young Peter was just five years old, his mother remarried. Peter’s stepfather was ill disposed towards him, and seemed to go out of the way to badger the boy. Unfortunately, his mother died of smallpox shortly after remarrying which left Peter vulnerable to his stepfather.

It didn’t take long for his stepfather to send young Peter Conser on his way. He soon found a home with a man named Ainetubby, but that was short lived as well. He worked for his room and board until Ainetubby passed away a year after, and young Peter once again had to find a new home. He soon found it at the Gilbert Perry home. Unfortunately, not much is known of his life during this time, but it can be assumed that whatever happened didn’t fully prepare him from the events that were soon to come.

Through the Civil War

When the American Civil War broke out in 1860, the fate of Indian Territory was still in doubt. Each individual Indian nation had to decide whether to side with the pro-slavery south or the slave free north.  The Choctaws, in general, were more favorable to the southern cause.

In the early months of 1862, the Choctaws joined with the Confederate force.  In retaliation, Union forces began to invade the Choctaw nation.  Many of those who were not involved in the fighting fled south to the Red River for protection. 

After several days of hard travel, Peter stopped for the night at the plantation of Robert M. Jones.  Robert was a wealthy and generous Choctaw, and offered Peter a place to stay.  Tired, cold, and hungry Peter gratefully accepted. 

Though Peter was only ten years old when he arrived at the plantation, he quickly dedicated himself to helping Robert run the farm.  Over the next few years, Peter would pick up skills that he would use throughout his life.  It was also during this time that Peter shed the remains of his old life.  Vowing to create a better life for himself, he changed his name from Peter Coinson to Peter Conser.

The Road to Prosperity

Once the American Civil War was over, Peter returned to the Hodges area that he had known as a child.  With a small amount of seed corn and knowledge gained from his time on the plantation, Conser reestablished himself on an abandoned farm.  It was during this time that Conser married his first wife, Amy Bacon, a Choctaw, and the couple had one child.  After arriving in the Hodges area, Conser once again dedicated himself to hard work, and his efforts paid off.  A combination of good farmland and careful planning helped him overcome his impoverished youth. 

Conser’s newfound prosperity brought social recognition.  In 1877, when he was only 25 years old, Conser aligned himself politically with the very prominent McCurtain brothers. That same year, he was appointed deputy sheriff of Sugarloaf County in the Choctaw nation. 

As with everything he did, he tackled that position with great fearlessness and integrity.  It didn’t take long before be distinguished himself as a respected leader among the Choctaw Indian.  In 1881, under Chief Jack McCurtain, Peter Conser was appointed as a captain of the Choctaw Lighthorseman in Moshulatubbee district.

Life as a Choctaw Lighthorseman and the Birth of a Town

In the days before statehood, each separate tribe was in charge of policing the tribe’s territories.  The few American forts in the area didn’t have the capacity to police the entire Indian Territory, nor were they allowed to by federal law.  The forts were established to protect the white man from the Indian, rather than enforcing the Indian laws.  The only resource the white man were the few marshals headquartered in Fort Smith, and they did little to curb the stem of violence in the Indian Territory.  The real control lied with the Lighthorsemen.

The Lighthorsemen were the mounted police of the Five Civilized Tribes.  In the 1820’s, the Lighthorse had absolute control over law enforcement in Indian Territory.  By the time that Conser was appointed, their power had significantly declined.  In the 1870’s, the Lighthorse had been stripped of their judicial power.  Rather than retaining absolute control over Indian Territory, they became more of a peacekeeping force. 

Still, this did not negate Conser’s duties.  He was responsible for not only preserving order and discipline among his men, but also had to ensure that they were always ready for any situation that may arise.

While serving as captain in the Choctaw Lighthorse occupied the majority of his days, Conser continued working on his farm with the same devotion of his early days.  Still, while he may have thought that the turbulent days of his youth was over, life had other plans for him.  When Conser’s first wife Amy died, he married Martha Jane Smith.  This marriage was to bring Conser closer to the next stage in his life.  Over the next few years, they had eight children together, four boys and four girls.  In addition to everything else he had going on in his life, Conser also served as first a representative and then a senator in the Choctaw Council.

As his influence grew, so did his need for more land and a bigger home.  Eventually, this need could no longer be ignored.  The need for stabling space for the Lighthorse mounts and more space for his large family led Conser to build a new home near Heavener.

Peter constructed a two-story home with eight rooms.  It was in this house that his last child, a boy, died in childbirth with his mother.  The two were buried together in 1894, soon after completion of the house.  It was also on this land that the small town of Conser was born.

In addition to the small farm that Conser ran, he also expanded his business dealings by opening a general store, gristmill, sawmill and a blacksmith shop.  Understanding the need for a proper education, which Conser himself never received, he also built a small schoolhouse – the first in the area – for his children to attend. 

Within the general store, the U.S. government had authorized a small post office.  Conser’s wife, Martha, had been appointed postmistress of the Conser post office.  She retained that office until her death in 1894.

Peter Conser was 42 when Martha died.  Not long after her death, Conser married Mary Ann Holson, who was later named postmistress. She held this position until the general store and post office were destroyed in the 1920’s.

The remainder of Peter Conser’s life was uneventful.  Peter died in 1934.  He will always be remembered as a stern but fair lawman, loving father, generous neighbor and a courageous individual.

Visiting The Peter Conser house

The two-story 19th century home that Peter Conser lived in for the last half of his life still stands as it once did. It has been restored and furnished with items reflective of the family’s wealth and position.

The home remained in the Conser family until 1967. That year, Ms. Lewis Barnes, a granddaughter of Peter Conser, and her husband donated the house to the Oklahoma Historical Society. Now the home is a unique museum offers a glimpse back into time, back into the life of a man who started life as an orphan but through determination and perseverance had grown to be one of the greatest men in the Choctaw Nation.

The museum is one of the most unique and informative in the area. The restoration has been magnificently done, and the guide has a way of bringing the past to life. There is a story that he tells about upstairs guest bedroom. Peter Conser would occasionally use this room as a prison. The room locks from the outside, in order to keep his family safe from the criminals that would occasionally be held in the room. One can almost imagine the guard standing right outside the room, leaning against the upstairs banister, shotgun propped up beside him, just waiting for the opportunity to use it.

This and many other stories await your visit at the Peter Conser Home…

Peter Conser Home (Mailing Address)

47114 Conser Creek Rd.

Heavner, OK 74937

(918) 653-2493

A markerpeter conser house -
Peter Conser House, Oklahoma 74937, USA
[get directions]

More by this Author

Comments 7 comments

jdconser 5 years ago

Very well written with one factual error. I am the great-grandson of Peter Conser and my father, Preston, was raised by his grandfather in the pictured home. T. X. Coinson, Peter's father, was a Swiss immigrant from the Canton of Bern. He spoke french, but was not a citizen of that country.

Urbane Chaos profile image

Urbane Chaos 5 years ago from Wister, Oklahoma Author

JDConser, thanks for the correction! I always do my best to provide factual content, but, as with anything, an error does slip through the crack.

It must be a high privilege being the great-grandson of such a highly esteemed man. Thanks for the comment!

RMcLellan 4 years ago

One mistake that stood out to me - Heavener is spelled incorrectly in the address line.

I'm surprised the address is a Heavener one, really. I always thought of that area as Hodgens and Conser. =)

Thanks for the nice article!

Urbane Chaos profile image

Urbane Chaos 4 years ago from Wister, Oklahoma Author

Thanks for the correction! Since it's in the address, I don't think I would have ever noticed that!

Jeff Fortney 3 years ago

Great article. I would love to know where you came across the information of Peter with RM Jones. I'm looking into RM Jones for a dissertation and would love any additional information. If you have any, could you contact me at (or I will check back here)

Urbane Chaos profile image

Urbane Chaos 3 years ago from Wister, Oklahoma Author

Sorry Jeff, I missed this one.

The information came from an interview that we conducted with a descendant of Peter Conser. She can be contacted through the number for the Peter Conser home that's listed above. They also have a lot of other literature that they would be willing to share.

Colin Kelley 5 months ago

The article touches on Peter Conser's political connections which he used to his advantage when he avoided being convicted of murder after he participated in the killing Charles B. Wilson. As a Choctaw his case was handled in the Choctaw court and Conser was not convicted but a non-Choctaw who was also involved, Jack Crow, was tried on the same charge in Judge Parkers court in Ft. Smith, convicted and hanged.

The Chronicles of Oklahoms, Fall 2008, Vol lxxxvi #3.

Another Choctaw told me in person that he once visited Mr. Conser asking his help in getting a job and was told that yes Mr. Conser would get him the job if the person would pay him a high fee and since the man did not have that kind of money he did not get the job.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.

    Click to Rate This Article