Reasons for American Entry Into WWII
World War II was a terrible event that will be remembered as one of the darkest chapters in human history. With estimates of the dead ranging from 60 to 80 million, it is unthinkable to imagine that this event was allowed to fester and erupt as it did. Many in the United States simply figured the problems of Europe would be contained to that continent. However, a new enemy brought the war to our shores.
When the war began, the United States had entered a period of isolationism. Americans viewed the conflict as Europe’s problem and wished to keep it that way. However, as the situation in Europe grew increasingly dire, the United States began to slowly edge toward war. The breaking point, of course, was the sudden attack by the Japanese at Pearl Harbor. However, in retrospect, the attack may not have been such a sudden and unforeseen event. Tensions between the United States and Japan had been consistently escalating for several years before the attack.
While the United States was suffering through the economic meltdown of the Great Depression, Japan was fervently digging its way out of a financial crisis of its own. The Japanese decided that their best hope for survival hinged in their ability to expand militarily. In following this philosophy, the Japanese attacked and occupied the southern region of Manchuria in the fall of 1931. The purpose of this attack was to give Japan a territory rich in raw materials on the mainland. The only problem was that Manchuria was already under the control of China and was an area of strategic importance to the USSR.
Japan Invades Manchuria
Although the United States distrusted the USSR because of the recent communist takeover, the two nations maintained relatively sociable relations at the time. Irritated that the Japanese had moved into their backyard, the USSR began to strongly criticize the Japanese and began to posture militarily in the northern Manchuria region. Due to the United States' relatively amicable relations with both the USSR and China, it too began to publicly criticize the Japanese for their increasing aggression.
The United States cautioned Japan against further aggressive actions by threatening to cut off shipments of raw materials to the nation. This was an especially risky situation for Japan, its only source of oil and metal came from the United States, while their primary source of rubber came from the British territories in Malaya. Therefore, it would seem that the nation would have to tread lightly to avoid angering the West. Or would it?
In a surprising act of defiance, Japan promptly separated from the League of Nations, which was the precursor to the United Nations. Tensions continued to mount in the region for several years until 1937 when Japan entered full scale military combat with the economically depressed nation of China. This conflict became known as the Second Sino-Japanese War, which would later be singled out as the starting point of World War II in the Pacific Theater.
In the fall of 1940, Japan met with Nazi Germany and fascist-controlled Italy to create an alliance known as the Tripartite Pact. Under this agreement, these three nations agreed to work with and support each other in their respective countries’ efforts to create a new world order.
The United States responded by beginning to funnel money and equipment to the embattled Chinese. This aid, covered under the Lend-Lease Act, was a tool used by the United States to provide aid to friends and allies without having to directly become involved in conflict. Also receiving aid from the United States were Great Britain and the USSR as those nations struggled to fend of the growing Nazi threat in Europe.
This move further agitated the Japanese and began to turn an already very uneasy relationship into an outright hostile one. Although the Japanese had angered the West and isolated itself from the world, the nation continued its aggressive tactics. In line with this militaristic movement, the nation then attempted a takeover of French Indo-China. The West had officially had enough of Japan’s belligerence and promptly cut off supplies of natural resources to the regime.
Unable to continue its hopes of regional domination without an adequate supply of natural resources, the Japanese devised an alternative plan. They would take over the oil-rich Dutch East-Indies and British Malaya, thereby giving the nation an infinite supply of natural resources. However, the Japanese knew that the United States and the West would not let this happen without a fight. The Japanese surmised that to even the odds they would have to reduce the capabilities of the U.S. Navy in the Pacific region. Therefore, the plot to attack Pearl Harbor was developed.
We all know what happened next, the attack on Pearl Harbor was initially a striking blow to the United States’ ability to wage war in the Pacific. Japan was left unchecked and was able to mop up what was remaining of the United States military in the Pacific, promptly taking Guam, the Philippines, British Malaya, and many other small islands and territories in short succession. The morning after the attack on Pearl Harbor, December 8, 1941, the United States declared war on Japan.
True to the agreement of the Tripartite Pact, Germany and Italy declared war on the United States on December 11, 1941. Interestingly, the United States was slow to respond to Japan militarily. Instead, President Roosevelt and British Prime Minister Winston Churchill devised a strategy to vanquish the European threat before fully concentrating on defeating Japan; this became known as the Europe First or Germany First strategy. Although Japan was a serious threat, the Allied leaders determined that they could be contained to the Pacific region; after all the Japanese were bogged down with the war in China. While conversely, the Nazi’s had wreaked havoc and destruction across all of Europe and even portions of Africa.
Therefore in a surprising twist, the United States went from being attacked by the Japanese to attacking the Axis powers in Europe in only a matter of days. This has led some to speculate that President Roosevelt somehow orchestrated or welcomed the attack on Pearl Harbor as a way to allow the United States to slip into the war in Europe. However, there were many signs that the United States’ entry into the war in Europe may have been inevitable regardless of the events at Pearl Harbor.
Tensions between the United States and Germany had been tense since the end of World War I. Nazi leader Adolf Hitler saw the United States as a weak yet overbearing nation that consistently meddled in the affairs of other nations. Hitler saw the USA as an ideological enemy, racially mixed and therefore inferior. He also assumed America would be busy fighting Japan while Germany concentrated on taking over the USSR. With the threat from the USSR vanquished he would then be free to finish off Britain with little interference from the Americans.
Much of Hitler’s rationale for carrying out his war and anti-Semitism came about due to the repercussions of World War I. An Austrian by birth, Hitler had served in the German Army in World War I. According to reports, he was utterly devastated when Germany was defeated. So much so in fact, that he never fully recovered from the embarrassment. He began to blame Jews, Communism, and Western meddling for the despair that had befallen Germany. Determined to see the nation restored to her previous glory, Hitler soon joined a growing movement called the National Socialist German Workers Party or Nazi Party.
The party came to see the Treaty of Versailles, the agreement that ended World War I, as responsible for the destruction of German pride and success. The Treaty of Versailles had been predominantly constructed by the Allied nations of the English, French, and the United States. The treaty was designed in such a matter that Germany would be punished severely for its role in World War I, yet it should be lenient enough to allow Germany to resist the communist movement that was underway in the USSR.
Under the agreement, Germany was allowed to possess no submarines, no military aircraft, and only a few naval vessels. The nation was also forbidden to once again unite with Austria, or create any more secret treaties. And to top it off, Germany had to make reparation payments to the nations that it had attacked. President Woodrow Wilson had little interest in harshly punishing Germany. Instead, he championed the aim of creating a treaty that would allow Europe to handle any future conflicts without the help of the United States.
Treaty of Versailles
This mentality began to permeate the United States and culminated in the creation of the Neutrality Acts in the 1930’s. In essence, the Neutrality Acts tied the hands of the United States to help its allies by refusing to sell resources or loaning cash to any war combatants. However, the Neutrality Acts did have some shortcomings which allowed many American businesses to continue supplying resources to whomever they pleased. Nevertheless, as far as the United States government was concerned the country was to keep the sole focus on itself and remain isolationist.
While the Treaty of Versailles had been developed to remain somewhat lenient, Germans saw it as anything but. Instead, it was viewed as a punishment that was meant to embarrass Germany that was sucking the lifeblood from their nation. “The loss of vital industrial territory would be a severe blow to any attempts by Germany to rebuild her economy. Coal from the Saar and Upper Silesia in particular was a vital economic loss. Combined with the financial penalties linked to reparations, it seemed clear to Germany that the Allies wanted nothing else but to bankrupt her (historylearningsite.co.uk/treaty_of_versailles.htm, np, 2011)”.
This sentiment proved to be true as Germany's unemployment rate and inflation began to paralyze the nation's economy. The United States tried to step in and help by introducing the Young Plan in 1929. However this arrangement soured when the United States entered the Great Depression later that same year. The economic instability in the United States created a massive wave of financial collapse around the world, including Germany. In 1933, Hitler and the Nazi Party were able to take control of the German government and immediately set about undoing the Treaty of Versailles. Hitler immediately set about rebuilding Germany’s military forces, to levels that far exceeded the maximum set forth in the Treaty of Versailles. The nation also began to rebuild prohibited military equipment such as military aircraft, tanks, naval vessels, and artillery.
In 1936, the German military invaded and occupied an area called the Rhineland that had been set aside as a demilitarized zone by the Treaty of Versailles. As Hitler had predicted, none of the Allied nations responded to this flagrant breach of the treaty. This lack of a response only served to embolden the Nazi's. Knowing that violating the Treaty of Versailles would have virtually no repercussions, Germany began swallowing up Europe through trickery, lies, and force. When Germany invaded Poland, President Roosevelt was finally able to persuade Congress to allow the exchange of war materials to our allies on a cash and carry basis only.
However, it wasn’t until Europe was on the brink of total collapse that the United States began to seriously intervene. In July of 1940, France surrendered to Germany, leaving only England and the USSR to fight the Nazi onslaught in Europe. Hitler knew that the only hopes for England's survival depended on aid from the United States and the USSR. However, he also knew that he would not be able to wage a successful campaign against the American's on their home soil. Therefore, he decided to postpone his attack on Britain and instead focus on eliminating the USSR. Germany believed that this would create such a size disparity that it would be impossible for the United States to wage any type of campaign in Europe.
Due in part to increasingly hostile run-ins with Nazi warships and submarines, such as the attacks on the SS Robin Moore and the USS Rueben James, President Roosevelt finally convinced Congress to break away from the Neutrality Act and activate the Lend-Lease Act. The United States then began sending massive amounts of military equipment and financial support to both Britain and Russia, instituted a military draft, and expanded its naval boundaries. The United States also agreed to supply Britain with 50 naval destroyers in exchange for several military bases in the Atlantic and Pacific.
To protect the shipments of these goods provided under the Lend-Lease Act, the United States Navy then began to escort Allied shipping convoys across the Atlantic. Hitler began to sense that President Roosevelt had been increasing naval activity in the area simply to create an incident that the United States could claim as an act of war. Therefore, on the eve of Germany’s invasion of the USSR, he ordered his naval forces in the Atlantic to not fire on American ships under any circumstance.
However, the USSR proved to be a much tougher opponent than predicted and was able to slow the Nazi advancement. This bought some time and allowed the United States and England to further fine-tune their strategy. In the fall of 1941, President Roosevelt and Winston Churchill met and established the Atlantic Charter. The agreement set forth the goals for the postwar years, such as freedom of the seas, access to raw materials, global cooperation, and self-government. Most importantly, it called openly for “the final destruction of the Nazi tyranny”.
Indeed, the United States was well on its way to war regardless of its isolationist attitude. It was something that President Roosevelt had come to realize over the years as the Nazi’s continued their path of destruction. In a speech given by the president at the commencement address of the University of Virginia in 1940, he indicated that the United States would have to intervene at some point. He explained that the United States’ view that an isolationist mentality could protect us was delusional, and the evil spreading across Europe would inevitably reach our shores.
Further driving the United States away from its isolationist policies and mindset was the recent advent of motion pictures and radio. These new technologies allowed the American people to see and hear unfolding events in distant places as they never had been able to before. Movie theaters showed the atrocities occurring in Europe and Asia to the masses and radio described the harrowing events in detail. Even before the United States entered the war, the American people began to dislike Hitler and there was a growing sentiment that he had to be stopped.
Although the American people and Roosevelt were beginning to sense an inevitable intervention, the president knew that he would not be able to convince Congress to declare war until the events directly affected the United States. After all, Congress had only recently allowed for the enactment of the Lend-Lease Act. It was also the same Congress that had sat idly by and let the world descend into chaos. Therefore, convincing them to take action was going to be an uphill battle to say the least.
It wasn’t until the attack on Pearl Harbor that President Roosevelt was finally able to convince Congress to allow an American response. An interesting side-note, there was still one Congress member that voted against America entering the war. Jeannette Rankin of Montana refused to allow an American response to the attack on Pearl Harbor. Nevertheless, the remaining members of Congress relented and finally allowed for an American intervention in the war.