The American Civil War: Battle of Gettysburg

James is an online writer from Birmingham who has a keen interest in ancient history. He enjoys sharing his research with his readers.

Introduction

For General Robert E. Lee, the stunning Confederate victory at Chancellorsville in May 1863 provided both his crowning achievement and his darkest moment of battlefield command.

Although the Union army under General Joseph Hooker had been routed, Lee’s most capable lieutenant, General Thomas J. ‘Stonewall’ Jackson, had been mortally wounded by friendly fire. Although the loss of Jackson was a severe blow, Lee nevertheless felt compelled to follow up the victory at Chancellorsville. He reorganised the Army of Northern Virginia into three corps, commanded by generals James Longstreet, A.P. Hill and Richard S. Ewell.

The Confederate army was flush with victory and stood at the height of its strength; therefore, its commander looked to the north for a second time. Lee’s aims were similar to those that had precipitated the invasion of the north, which had ended nine months earlier with the battle of Antietam.

Destroying the Pennsylvania Railroad Bridge over the Susquehanna River would disrupt enemy communications, and Confederate troops could sustain themselves with supplies procured from Northern farms. Lee might capture Harrisburg, the Pennsylvanian state capital, and threaten Baltimore, Philadelphia or Washington, DC. Perhaps most important, the population of the north was becoming war-weary. The presence of victorious Confederate forces in Union territory might bring peace overtures and secure Southern independence.

The Campaign

On the 3rd of June 1863, the Army of Northern Virginia began streaming steadily to the northwest, across the mountains of the Blue Ridge, and then northward through the Shenandoah Valley. The Confederates operated virtually at will for three weeks against only token resistance. With Ewell’s corps in the van, the Confederates were spread across miles of the Pennsylvania countryside. By the end of the month, Ewell was menacing Harrisburg; General Jubal Early’s division had occupied the town of York, and Robert Rodes’ division was miles to the north at Carlisle.

Hooker’s Army of the Potomac became alerted to the Confederate offensive on the 25th of June, during a heavy clash between Rebel cavalry under General J.E.B. Stuart and Federal horsemen commanded by General Alfred Pleasanton at Brandy Station, Virginia. Hooker set his army in motion to intercept the Confederates and requested that the arsenal at Harpers Ferry be abandoned, and its garrison of 10,000 men added to the field army’s ranks.

When President Lincoln and the Union army’s general-in-chief, Henry W. Halleck, declined, Hooker asked to be relieved of command. On the 28th of June, a mere four days before the battle of Gettysburg, General George G. Meade was placed in command of the Army of the Potomac.

The rapid northwest movement of the Union army caused Stuart to initiate a lengthy ride around Meade and out of contact with Lee. Thus, during a critical period of the campaign, the Confederate commander was deprived of his eyes and ears. Lee, warned by a Southern sympathiser, knew for certain only that the Army of the Potomac was on the march. Without intelligence from Stuart, he had no choice but to concentrate his forces. Reluctantly, Lee ordered Ewell to abandon his planned attack on Harrisburg and join the corps of Hill and Longstreet in Gettysburg.

Highly Recommended Links

• Gettysburg is an Endangered Battlefield
  An article exploring the possibility of America's most famous battlefield transforming into a massive casino.
• Did Lt. Gen. Richard Ewell Lose the Battle of Gettysburg
  An article that explores General Ewell's decision to disobey Lee's orders to avoid a general engagement, which may have cost the Confederacy the battle.

In Search Of Shoes

On the morning of the 1^st July, Lee was with Longstreet’s Corps at Chambersburg, 25 miles west of Gettysburg. Hill’s Corps was 8 miles west of Gettysburg at Cashtown. Neither Lee nor Meade intended to fight at Gettysburg, which held virtually no strategic value. Lee, in fact, had admonished his subordinate commanders not to bring on a general engagement until the army could be concentrated on favourable ground. Events, however, soon began to develop beyond the control of either senior commander.

Early had already passed through Gettysburg on the 26^th June during his division’s march to York. He sent a note to Hill, informing him that a cache of shoes might be found in the town. Four days later, the leading division of Hill’s corps under General Henry Heth, reached Cashtown. Heth sent a brigade down the Chambersburg Pike to Gettysburg in search of the shoes. The brigade commander, General James Pettigrew, withdrew from the Gettysburg area when he spotted a large force of Union cavalry moving up from the south. On the 1^st July, Hill ordered two full divisions, those of Heth and General Dorsey Pender, to Gettysburg to determine the strength of the Union force. Probing eastward, the Confederates found two brigades of General John Buford’s cavalry, screening the advance of the left wing of the Army of the Potomac. Buford had ordered his troopers to dismount and take up defensive positions west of the town and waited for the Rebels to return.

The decisive battle of the American Civil War was taking shape while the bulk of both armies and both senior commanders were not present on the field. Buford’s decision to stand and fight combined with Hill’s decision to send a force much greater than necessary on a reconnaissance mission precipitated an engagement from which neither side could readily extricate itself.

The First Day

Buford’s dismounted cavalrymen fought like lions against ever-increasing numbers of Confederate infantrymen. For two hours, they stood firm before the infantry of General John F. Reynolds’ I Corps rolled in from the south. As he urged the famed Iron Brigade forward, Reynolds was killed in the saddle by a Confederate sharpshooter. Both sides committed fresh troops to the fray, and the fighting intensified. Union troops from New York and Wisconsin captured more than 200 Rebel soldiers, who had been trapped in the cut of an unfinished railroad. Hard pressed, other Union troops fought desperately to prevent their left flank from being turned.

From about 4 miles away, Ewell and Rodes, on the march from Carlisle, could hear Hill’s artillery firing. By now, elements of the Union XI Corps, under General Oliver O. Howard, were shuffling through the streets of Gettysburg towards the fighting. The Confederate generals, however, recognised an opportunity to hit the exposed Union right flank. Eventually, the combined weight of Rodes’ assaults, the renewed effort of Heth’s division, and advances by three of Pender’s brigades threatened to overwhelm the Union I Corps on Seminary Ridge.

It was however, the XI Corps on the Union right which gave way first. Raising a cloud of dust on the Harrisburg Road, Early’s division appeared from the north and routed a Union division, which had taken up positions on a small knoll. Georgia, Louisiana and North Carolina troops stunned the Union right and successive units of the XI Corps faltered, broke and ran through the town to the relative safety of Cemetery Hill.

With its flank fully exposed, the patchwork battle line of the Union I Corps on Seminary Ridge collapsed. Streaming back through Gettysburg, more and more Union troops reached Cemetery Hill, where General Winfield Scott Hancock, commander of the II Corps, had become the fifth general of the day to command the Union forces. Meade would not reach Gettysburg from Taneytown, Maryland until after midnight. Lee had arrived on the field at 1:30 pm but was largely a bystander during most of the fighting.

As the Union troops scrambled to consolidate their position on Cemetery Hill, Lee grasped the significance of his opportunity to win a decisive victory. He forwarded a cryptic verbal order to Ewell, which said in effect that it was only necessary to ‘press those people’ in order to take possession of the heights and to capture Cemetery Hill, nearby Culp’s Hill or both ‘if practicable.’

The fight, however, had gone out of Ewell. The enemy beyond Cemetery Hill was of undetermined strength. Hill’s corps was spent. Longstreet would not reach Gettysburg for hours. Under protest from subordinates, Ewell declined to continue his attack. During the night, Union reinforcements continued to arrive, Culp’s Hill was occupied in force, and a defensive line was established across Cemetery Ridge to Little Round Top. Ewell’s decision remains, to this day, one of the most controversial of the entire Civil War.

State Of The Battle

The Harvest Of Death

The Second Day

In the early hours of the 2^nd July, both sides held councils of war. Meade was determined to stand, despite the fact that the rest of the Union army had yet to reach Gettysburg. Lee, acting against the advice of Longstreet, decided that an attack on the Union left combined with a renewed effort against Cemetery Hill and Culp’s Hill might negate Meade’s advantage of interior lines and roll up the entire Union position.

Longstreet took pains to conceal his march to his designated jump-off position and was not ready to attack until about 3:30 pm. Confederate artillery fired on the positions of the exposed Union division commanded by General Daniel Sickles in the Peach Orchard as infantrymen from Alabama and Texas marched to the east and turned northward towards Little Round Top and a jumble of huge boulders known locally as Devil’s Den. Major General Gouverneur K. Warren, the chief engineer of the Army of the Potomac, rode to the summit of Little Round Top as the Confederates massed for their assault. He recognised that if the Confederates captured this key hill an enfilading fire would render the entire Union line untenable. Warren searched frantically for troops to defend the position. His plea for help was answered by two brigades of General George Sykes’ V Corps. These troops from Pennsylvania, New York, and Maine scrambled into position moments before the attacking Confederates started up the slope.

While the desperate defenders of Little Round Top, scavenging ammunition from their own dead and wounded, beat back multiple attacks, fighting raged nearby. Successive Confederate assaults shattered Sickles’ salient in the Peach Orchard, and the Wheatfield became a scene of tremendous carnage. At the end of the day, Longstreet had overrun Devil’s Den and his troops controlled the Peach Orchard. However, thanks to Warren’s initiative, Little Round Top was in Union hands.

At Culp’s Hill and Cemetery Hill, Ewell sent troops from the divisions of Early and General Edward Johnson forward in the fading light. Fighting continued for several hours as the Confederates made headway. Some of Early’s troops reached the crest of Culp’s Hill and engaged in hand-to-hand fighting with the defenders. While the rest of his line was unmolested, Hancock was able to reinforce the threatened area, and by 10 pm the fighting had petered out.

The Third And Final Day

The High Water Mark

The Third Day

The climatic day at Gettysburg began on the Union right at Culp’s Hill and Spangler’s Spring, where Confederate forces still held earthworks dug by the Federals on the night of the 1^st July. At daylight, further Confederate attacks against the strong entrenchments on Culp’s Hill proved fruitless. Two Union divisions under Generals Thomas Ruger and John Geary rooted elements of Johnson’s division out of their hard-won but meagre lodgement. Before noon, the Federals had regained their lost earthworks, and the fighting had ebbed. A strange silence now hung over the field. It was a deceptive quiet, for the final act of the Gettysburg drama was to unfold in a few short hours.

Lee apparently reasoned that Meade had left his centre vulnerable to attack by reinforcing his flanks. Therefore, a concentrated blow against the Union centre on Cemetery Ridge might break through the line. Longstreet strongly dissented. The attacking troops would be obliged to cross more than a mile of open ground and traverse a picket fence along the Emmitsburg Road, all the while exposed to artillery fire from massed guns on Cemetery Ridge and the heights at either end of the Union line.

Most of Lee’s army had been heavily engaged on the 2^nd July, and the only substantial force available to mount such an assault was the division of General George Pickett, which had guarded Confederate supply wagons for the previous two days. Pickett commanded three brigades, led by Generals Richard B. Garnett, James L. Kemper and Lewis A. Armistead. These would be supported by the divisions of Joseph Pettigrew and Isaac Trimble, who had assumed command for the wounded Heth and Pender respectively. The attacking force would number roughly 15,000 men.

At 1pm, nearly 150 Confederate guns opened a cannonade against the Union centre. Soon, approximately 80 Union cannon replied from Cemetery Ridge. The artillery duel continued for two hours. Then, at 3pm, Pickett shouted. ‘Up men and to your posts! Don’t forget today that you are from Old Virginia!’

Pickett’s troops stepped off to the northeast, wheeled with parade ground precision to the east, and headed towards the Union centre. Their objective was a large copse of trees on the crest of Cemetery Ridge. As they crossed the open fields, Union artillery began to tear large gaps in the Confederate ranks. Then, as the Rebels came closer, Union infantry opened fire from the low stone wall to the front of the charging mass and against both of its flanks. Following the battle, the sharp 90 degree angle of the wall came to be known simply as The Angle.

Garnett was killed, and General Kemper fell seriously wounded. On foot, Armistead led his men through a momentary breach in the Union line, waving his hat perched atop his sword. As he laid his hand on a Union cannon, Armistead was mortally wounded. No Confederate reinforcements were available to exploit the breakthrough, and Union troops steadily closed on both flanks. At long last, the shattered remnants of the famous Pickett’s Charge limped back towards their own lines, having achieved nothing but immortality. The high tide of the Confederacy had smashed itself upon the rock of the Union centre.

A Lasting Memorial

Aftermath

On the 4^th July Lee began a long retreat to Virginia, his dream of a military victory on Northern soil dashed. That same day, the Confederate city of Vicksburg, Mississippi, surrendered, and the South was split in two. These devastating defeats sealed the fate of the Confederacy. In the three day orgy of death and destruction at Gettysburg, the Union suffered 3149 killed and 19,664 wounded or captured. The Confederacy suffered 4536 dead and 18,089 wounded or taken prisoner. On the 19^th November 1863, President Lincoln offered a short speech of slightly more than 200 words during the dedication of a new cemetery for the Union soldiers killed at Gettysburg. The Gettysburg Address still resonates nearly two centuries later.

© 2013 James Kenny

Comments

Jay C OBrien from Houston, TX USA on February 17, 2015:

Let us take a look at the Gettysburg Address from the viewpoint of the New Testament.

Lincoln says his purpose is to: “dedicate a portion of that field, as a final resting place to those who here gave their lives that nation might live.”

Would Jesus have consecrated a killing field and advocated killing again and again? Lincoln places nation above God. Who was/is more correct, Lincoln or Jesus?

Jesus taught to love one another. His final command to Peter was: sheath your sword. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. Love your enemies. All of these teachings go against fighting and killing in combat. Jesus never strapped on a sword. We should not dedicate land as sacred if killing was involved.

mySuccess8 on February 15, 2015:

Well-researched interesting key facts about one of the bloodiest battles of the Civil War, supported by great images. I have now learned a lot more about this famous battle. Congrats on Hub of the Day!

Heidi Thorne from Chicago Area on February 15, 2015:

Another great history hub! Congrats on Hub of the day. Well deserved!

AboutAustralia on February 15, 2015:

A very interesting hub, thank you. Congratulations on being awarded Hub of The Day! Well done, a great read. Sharon.

Michael Higgins from Michigan on February 15, 2015:

Fantastic hub, JKenny. I enjoyed the read! Great research. Congrats on HOTD!

Jay C OBrien from Houston, TX USA on February 15, 2015:

Let us not forget it is wrong to kill people. From the standpoint of the individual, it is better to do something constructive with your life than putting yourself in harm's way. Look for constructive alternatives rather than fighting. Land does Not become Holy or consecrated because you kill for it. Do not enmesh yourself in violence.

Patricia Scott from North Central Florida on February 15, 2015:

O hoping there is never a war again on our soil. I do read and reread the war years on our soil...and am saddened that we found no other way to resolve the issues ....slavery is never right, was not before our country had its humble beginnings, during the time it existed, and is wrong today.

I am currently rereading much history...this time period as well as the Revolutionary War period.

Well done Angels are on the way to you today ps

Guy Matthews on February 15, 2015:

How odd, I was just researching Gettysburg over my morning coffee as I have an interest in the Civil War. I later sign into HubPages to work on my own hubs and this is Hub of the Day! And they say there's no such thing as coincidence. Really enjoyed reading this, thanks!

Nell Rose from England on March 31, 2014:

I saw a message on the forum so I thought I would go and take a look, and I recognised some of them, but didn't realise who they belonged too. so copied and pasted the first paragraph, glad to help, go get em! lol!

James Kenny (author) from Birmingham, England on March 31, 2014:

Cheers Nell. I've posted a strong comment demanding they unpublish it. Hopefully that'll be enough. Thanks again. :)

Nell Rose from England on March 31, 2014:

Hi Kenny, just thought you would like to know that this is a copy of your hub:

http://documentariezblog.blogspot.co.uk/2014/03/th...

Nathan Orf on January 24, 2014:

I used to visit Gettysburg every year for a week of camping as a kid with my parents. We would go for the music festivals they hold there every March and August, and to visit the town of Gettysburg as it is today. I've seen the battlefield many, many times.

Great hub, JKenny, as always, but I strongly disagree with christopheranton and yourself with regards to secession. Taken as a constitutional issue, secession was viewed by the Union as treason, which is patently unconstitutional, the Framers having decided that states rights to self-determination had to be balanced by the nation and the people's right to peace and domestic tranquility. Lincoln did not immediately rush to war, nor did he immediately rush to emancipate the slaves; his entire focus, in the beginnings of the war, was in preserving the Union against what he, and the North, saw as an unlawful rebellion.

There is nothing wrong with self-determination per say, but that and states rights have been used too many times to justify what are clearly moral wrongs, whether it was slavery then, or segregation, or laws against same sex marriage today. The argument that the South had the right to self-determination is used most often as a glorifying cover story, the "Lost Cause." It is a myth; the real motivation for Southern secession was that the Aristocratic elites of the South feared that slavery would be lost to them. They chose to secede because they viewed this as the very last measure they could take to preserve the institution of slavery, in the name of self-determination.

James Kenny (author) from Birmingham, England on April 04, 2013:

Thank you very much Julie, I actually like studying maps, which is why I included quite a few. It's quite interesting to see how it all played out from a strategic point of view. Thanks for popping by.

Jools Hogg from North-East UK on April 03, 2013:

Another great article James. Great that you included the campaign map, though I have to study it for ages to make sense of it (maps are not my strong point).

James Kenny (author) from Birmingham, England on April 02, 2013:

Thank you very much Elias- glad to be of service.

James Kenny (author) from Birmingham, England on April 02, 2013:

Thank you very much Eddy! You too.

James Kenny (author) from Birmingham, England on April 02, 2013:

Thank you very much DDE!

Elias Zanetti from Athens, Greece on April 02, 2013:

A marvelously written and well documented article! I enjoyed the history lesson! Thank you! Voted up, useful&interesting! Cheers!

Eiddwen from Wales on April 02, 2013:

What a wonderful history lesson ; so interesting and well informed. Thank you for sharing .

Enjoy your day.

Eddy.

Devika Primić from Dubrovnik, Croatia on April 02, 2013:

An interesting outlook here on The American Civil War: Battle Of Gettysburg, so much to learn from.

James Kenny (author) from Birmingham, England on April 02, 2013:

Hi Chris, you make a very interesting point and it reminds me of a very famous saying: 'History is always written by the winners!' Yes the practice of slavery was wrong, but in basic terms the Confederacy had every right to break away from the Union. Thanks for popping by, always appreciated.

Christopher Antony Meade from Gillingham Kent. United Kingdom on April 01, 2013:

An interesting thought has just occurred to me. Apart from the slavery issue, the Confederacy was in the right in the American Civil War. According to the principle of self determination, they were entitled to secede from the United States. Lincoln was in the wrong. It all just goes to show that history and politics rarely really make sense.

Thanks James for yet another outstanding hub. I think this one deserves to be shared on Facebook and tweeted about.

Well done.

James Kenny (author) from Birmingham, England on April 01, 2013:

Thanks very much TravelinJack- like the username by the way!

Jack Baumann from St. Louis, Missouri on March 31, 2013:

Really love the recounting of one of the greatest battled of American History!