Updated date:

The Battle of Hayes Pond: When Native Americans Defeated the KKK

Bethany is a freelance writer with an interest in health and cultural issues. She is a member of the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma.

In the wake of the recent increase in high-profile displays of white nationalism and neo-Nazi sentiment, I've been thinking about how my own community has been affected by these types of extremists. Though I am not Lumbee, this story about the Lumbee and the KKK sticks in my mind. It shows how Native Americans have opposed these racist ideologies in the past.

Lumbee men confront Klansmen at the intended KKK rally

Lumbee men confront Klansmen at the intended KKK rally

When the landmark case Brown v. Board of Education called for the desegregation of schools, the Ku Klux Klan was not pleased. In fact, the impending integration energized and, to some extent, revived the Klan. In 1958, in Robeson County, North Carolina, this tide of racism culminated in one of the strangest battles in American history: the Battle of Hayes Pond.

What made Robeson County the setting for this drama? They had a unique racial mix, including 40,000 white residents, 30,000 Native Americans and 25,000 African Americans. They also had the attention of a Klan leader, James W. “Catfish” Cole who held particular ire toward the local Native American tribe, the Lumbee, whom he believed to be largely of African descent.

Klan leader James W. "Catfish" Cole

Klan leader James W. "Catfish" Cole

Before The Rally

In their typical style, the Robeson County Klan, as led by Catfish Cole, showed their anger through acts of nighttime terrorism. First, they burned a cross in the yard of a Lumbee woman who was dating a white man. Next, they burned a cross in the yard of a Lumbee family that had moved into a predominantly white neighborhood. Both of these, Cole said, where to send a strong message against “race-mixing” (qtd. in “New Battle, Old Problems”).

Around the same time, Cole announced that the Klan would hold a rally outside of the town of Maxton, at a place called Hayes Pond. The explicit purpose of the rally was to “put the Indians in their place” and to solve part of the “integration problem” (qtd. in “New Battle, Old Problems”). They chose to hold the rally in spite of clear warnings from the local police not to do so. That would turn out to be a mistake.

Lumbee men swarm the car of a Klan supporter

Lumbee men swarm the car of a Klan supporter

From Rally to Battle

About 100 Klansmen arrived in the field at Hayes Pond and set up their rally with only a KKK banner, a public address system powered by a portable generator, and a single light-bulb for illumination. The weak light cast by the bulb was insufficient to show the Klansmen that they were surrounded by hundreds of Lumbee, silent but angry.

Recommended for You

From there on, various accounts disagree on the precise events. However, it is clear that a Lumbee sharpshooter shot out the lightbulb, plunging the Klansmen into darkness and chaos. The two sides fell into fighting, both sides armed with both improvised weapons and firearms—though no one was seriously injured or killed. The Klansmen were overmatched and unprepared, and fled in terror, abandoning their friends, family, and pieces of Klan paraphernalia. Catfish Cole himself abandoned his wife, opting to flee through the woods without her. She then crashed their car into a ditch and had to be assisted by the victorious Lumbee.

Simeon Oxendine and Charlie Warriax laugh while wearing the KKK banner taken away by the tribe

Simeon Oxendine and Charlie Warriax laugh while wearing the KKK banner taken away by the tribe

The Aftermath

The Lumbee celebrated their victory in the field with singing and dancing. They collected and burned much of the Klan paraphernalia, though two of the leaders of the Lumbee resistance, Simeon Oxendine and Charlie Warriax, were photographed wrapped, laughing, in the abandoned KKK banner.

In the aftermath, the Klan was effectively driven out of Robeson County. The only people arrested after the rally were Cole and other Klansmen. Never again was a Klan rally or meeting held in Robeson County.



Michael Kerney on September 03, 2018:

See also "Battle of Hayes Pond," it's even on Wikipedia ffs.

Robert Levine from Brookline, Massachusetts on December 19, 2017:

Hello Bethany,

Thank you for this fascinating account of a historical incident I had never heard of before.

Incidentally, my father and his best friend ran the KKK out of my hometown of Greenbelt, Maryland one day in the early or mid-1960s. Greenbelt was all-white at the time, so they came to the town center to recruit new members. Apparently they didn't know that Greenbelt had a large Jewish population, or that, having been founded as part of the New Deal, it was staunchly liberal. The Klansmen drove up in a pick up truck & one of them started barking into a megaphone. My Dad & his best friend ran into the grocery store, bought as many tomatoes & eggs as they could, came back outside & let fly. The Klansmen immediately turned around & drove off.

Related Articles