Skip to main content

The Pre-Raphaelite Art Model: Fanny Antwistle Eaton

  • Author:
  • Updated date:

An arts major and published indie author who writes on various subjects pertaining to humanities.

Portrait of Fanny Eaton by Walter Fryer Stocks, circa 1859

Portrait of Fanny Eaton by Walter Fryer Stocks, circa 1859

Who Was Fanny Eaton?

Of all the celebrated female figures immortalized in the Pre-Raphaelite art movement, Fanny Ainswhite Eaton remains more special than any other muse. Androgynous and beautiful, Fanny’s refined Caribbean features would come to inspire some of the most famous artists of the Victorian Era. In time, art critics would come to recognize her as one of the foremost art models of her time.

Eaton's story is important. Not only does she have a rightful place among these other models, but her life and visual presence also epitomize the 'Other' in Victorian society.

— Roberto C. Ferrari, Curator of Art Properties at Avery Architectural & Fine Arts Library, Columb

Jamaican Immigrant of African Descent

Fanny Antwistle Eaton was born in St. Andrew, Surrey, Jamaica in 1835, to Matilda Foster, an unwed former plantocracy slave of African descent. Some researchers have theorized that following the Great Jamaican Slave Revolt of 1831–32 and the emancipation of slaves in 1833, Foster, like many others given freedom, sought a better life elsewhere because of poor labor conditions. By the 1840s, census records show mother and daughter migrating to England.

According to art curator and researcher Roberto C. Ferrari, both were living in London at the address 9 Steven’s Place in the parish of St. Pancras. Matilda’s choice to migrate to London had been a wise decision in that she had elevated her family’s standing in life, given the racial tension that remained stewing in Jamaica after a tumultuous decade of insurrection and uncertainty.

Painting depicting the burning of Roehampton Estate during the Great Jamaican Slave Revolt  in Jamaica by Adolphe Duperly 1833

Painting depicting the burning of Roehampton Estate during the Great Jamaican Slave Revolt in Jamaica by Adolphe Duperly 1833

Art Modeling Career at the Royal Academy of Arts

Fanny may have had very little hope. Growing up a multi-racial child was a challenge given strict Victorian standards which frowned at out-of-wedlock children. Yet at 16, she was hired on as a servant. It’s no wonder that in 1857, she ended up marrying James Eaton, a proprietary horse cab driver. With a husband to help provide better circumstances, she soon adjusted to marriage and motherhood, and to help make ends meet she hired herself out as an independent cleaning woman. However, it’s assumed that the work paid very little and with the worries of a growing family, she needed to supplement her family’s income. Hence, one reason she started modeling for artists at the Royal Academy of Arts.

It’s not known for certain how Fanny first came across her modeling position at the arts academy. It’s also possible that she might have worked in the home of someone associated with the arts who envisioned her potential. According to Ferrari, a more plausible scenario was through her association with Jewish artist Simeon Solomon, who first captured her unique face on canvas in the painting The Mother of Moses which premiered in 1861 to the public.

Royal Academy of Arts, London 19th Century

Royal Academy of Arts, London 19th Century

. . . having a very fine head and figure—a good deal of Janey.

— Dante Gabriel Rossetti, describing Eaton's likeness to androgynous art model Jane Burden Morris

Androgynous Appeal Reigns Supreme

In Victorian England, the typical image of female attractiveness remained centered on Caucasian women having a porcelain complexion and vibrant flowing hair. Yet, with the introduction of the Pre-Raphaelite movement, a brotherhood of Oxford artists who leaned toward the unconventional, the old idealized beauty standard which marginalized other ethnicities soon faded.

Instead, artists sought more exotic-looking women who appeared either androgynous or buxom in figure, redefining and epitomizing the new forward-thinking artistic movement. According to Ferrari, Fanny garnered much interest from formidable art talents such as Dante Gabriel Rossetti, John Everett Millais, Frederick Sandys, and Robert Hawker Dowling. In his own words, the curator explains the artist’s demand for her likeness:

“Eaton’s lighter complexion drew attention to her ‘Otherness’ as being neither white nor black. Her in-between features allowed the Pre-Raphaelites to represent her as numerous exotic characters, and indeed she was portrayed by them as Hebrew, Oriental, Indian, and so on.”

In 1865, the famed aforementioned artist Rossetti sketched Eaton, rendering her earthy and enigmatic likeness to another of his preferred muses, Jane Burden Morris. One of his most famous paintings included Eaton as a background figure in The Beloved, as featured in the thumbnail layout below.

Eaton's Later Years

Years later, by the time she turned 63, Fanny lived in Oakfield on the Isle of Wight, working as a domestic cook for a wine merchant family. By 1911, she returned to London to live with her children and grandchildren, where she died in March 1924 at 89 from encroaching senility and collapse.

Fanny Eaton in "The Mother of Sisera" Looked out a Window by  painter Albert Joseph Moore

Fanny Eaton in "The Mother of Sisera" Looked out a Window by painter Albert Joseph Moore

A Writer's Perspective

Most of the art models lived an irregular life by Victorian standards, yet Eaton's journey was even more unconventional because of her mixed-race identity. She faced many challenges in life, marrying young, bearing 10 children, and becoming a widow in her forties. That she continued working into her silver years shows us a determined spirit and humble existence, all the while her presence remained overshadowed and underrated in the Victorian art world.

Fanny did not receive the rave acclaim as other models because of the unfortunate social stigma over her ethnicity. Considering her prejudiced disadvantages, this art model deserves the utmost recognition. Fanny Antwistle Eaton remains my absolute favorite Pre-Raphaelite art model.

Animated Short Highlighting Fanny Eaton

Cited Sources & Works

  • Lydia Figes, "Fanny Eaton: Jamaican Pre-Raphaelite Muse" (23 Oct 2019) Art UK, Retrieved 14 Jan 2021
  • The Rossetti Archive
  • Kirsty Stonell Walker. Pre-Raphaelite Girl Gang: Fifty Makers, Shakers and Heartbreakers from the Victorian Era – Unicorn Publishing Group, February 15, 2020
  • The British Museum
  • Columbia/Academic Commons: Roberto C. Ferrari, Fanny Eaton: The 'Other' Pre-Raphaelite Model, Avery Architectural and Fine Arts Library, Nov. 8th, 2014. Retrieved 01/15/2021.

This content is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge and is not meant to substitute for formal and individualized advice from a qualified professional.

© 2021 ziyena