The Achievements and Faults of Qin Shihuang, The First Emperor of China

Emperor Qin Shihuang

Before the early third century BC, what is now known as China was nothing but a number of warring states. In 221 BC, Qin Shihuang, king of Qin (from which the name of the country derives), united China and became the first emperor of China. In terms of his long-lasting impact on the history of China, Qin Shihuang's life was marked with extraordinary achievement. However, from a more humanitarian point of view, those achievements came at great costs, perhaps to a fault.

Here is a look at some of Qin Shihuang's greatest achievements and greatest faults, and my analysis of which outweighs the other.

Qin Shihuang's Top Five Achievements

Qin Shihuang achieved quite a few significant accomplishments. These include:

• Uniting China
• Establishing the Qin dynasty
• Reinforcing legalism within the Chinese administrative system
• Restructuring political divisions to form a more coherent state
• Harmonising measurement units to allow for consistent, state-wide economic development
• Standardising the different Chinese scripts
• Building the Great Wall to protect the northern borders
• Constructing the Lingqu canal in the south to connect the major waterways and prevent flooding
• Building the overall infrastructure for national economic development
• Building the impressive Terracotta Army.

Here I will elaborate on what I consider to be the emperor's top five achievements.

1. Unifying China

The most important achievement under Qin Shihuang is the unification of China. After the Qin state conquered all others, ending the Warring States period, Qin Shihuang declared himself the first emperor—until that point, there had only been kings. With that, he founded the first Chinese dynasty. He continued to expand the Qin dynasty after unifying China, going as far south as Vietnam. This laid a solid foundation for future Chinese dynasties until the collapse of the Qing dynasty in the early 1900s.

The second most important of his achievements was the reinforcement of legalism within the Chinese administrative systems. The impact of this achievement far outlasted the Qin dynasty, and survives even under the current Communist rule.

Legalism is a Chinese philosophy best captured in The Book of Lord Shang. It assumes that people are essentially bad and that the only way to maintain public order is through strict laws and severe penalties. It had a great influence on the operation of the Qin dynasty.

Another important change was that meritocracy was valued over aristocracy within the government. The high officials and generals could be anybody who had the skill and the competence for those posts, and only the ruler of the state derived his privilege from birthright. This had a fundamental impact on future Chinese dynasties, in which examinations were introduced to promote people into government capacities, as opposed to inheriting the positions, as had been done in the past.

Qin Shihuang's third most important achievement was reforming the political arrangements to ensure China would not fall again into the divisive conflict of the Warring States period. To form a more coherent state, Qin Shihuang created commanderies, or military districts, within all the conquered states. He divided his empire into 36 commanderies in all, each run by a military governor. Within each commandery were a number of counties. The central government’s strong bond with its military commanderies prevented conflicts between states from turning into wars.

The fourth achievement was standardising everything from measurement units to writing scripts.

Economically, commerce was enhanced as currency, weights, roads and cart axle length were standardised. The development of roads and canals also created better connectivity between major trading regions.

Culturally, the writing script was standardised and made official throughout the dynasty. This created better internal communications for the state. All of these changes had very long-lasting impacts on later Chinese dynasties.

5. Building the Great Wall of China

Qin Shihuang also built the Great Wall of China to protect the dynasty from raids from the north. The construction of the wall lasted for 2,000 years after he began the project, and spans 13,171 mi (21,196 km) with all of its branches. It is so expansive that US Senator Jake Garn has said he could see the wall from space shuttle orbit. The wall is considered one of the Seven Wonders of the World.

This was not Qin Shihuang's only historic monument; he also built the impressive Terracotta Army in his pursuit of immortality. The army has over 8,000 figures, each personalized with facial details and holding actual weapons. The army was also accompanied by statues of chariots, horses, officials, acrobats, and musicians and was in fact part of an entire necropolis of offices, stables, and halls surrounding Qin Shihuang's mausoleum, built beneath a huge tomb mound. Qin Shihuang's mausoleum is now a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

Both of these constructions withstood the test of time and are still here today, providing great cultural sites for the people of the modern era.

Qin Shihuang's Two Major Faults

Qin Shihuang’s many faults and unattractive features derive in large part from his achievements.

One of his most well-known traits is harshness, which at times was considered despotic. He is said to have maintained strict order over his kingdom, and valued obedience above all. As the first ruler to have united many Warring States and subsequently impose a central government with astonishing alacrity, this trait may seem expected in some ways.

However, historical accounts should be taken with a grain of salt. Our only concrete sources about the Qin dynasty come largely from Han historians. Qin Shihuang's legalism, which believed strict rule was necessary because people inherently could not be trusted to govern themselves, was explicitly opposed to scholars' Confucianism, which believes that humans can and should try to improve themselves.From Qin Shihuang's legalist perspective, these views held by scholars were divisive, and consequently, scholars were persecuted in different ways, as seen below.

Ordinary people resented the Qin dynasty not only because of the emperor's harshness, but also because of legalism itself. While Qin Shihuang can be blamed partially for the faults of legalism, it was seen as the only way to unite the people and maintain order in the short term.

Qin Shihuang is most frequently faulted for the burning of books and burying of scholars. Technically it was not his idea, but that of Li Si to suppress thoughts and unify political and intellectual opinions by destroying books. The burning of books was also motivated by Qin Shihuang's desire to standardise scripts, because it was a method of removing books with non-standard writing. The many different political theories known as the ‘Hundred Schools of Thought’ and many history books were destroyed in the process, with the exception of books on legalism as well as a few on divination, medicine, agriculture, and war.

Historical accounts report that he buried alive between 400 and 700 scholars in the capital after being tricked by two alchemists. He was very concerned with mortality, as shown by his building the Terracotta Army as a monument to himself, and he was always looking for ways to extend his life through supernatural means.

Some of the scholars were also Confucians—despite his first son’s advice to not do so, Qin Shihuang continued to suppress the philosophy. This was perhaps the greatest shock to his dynasty’s foundation, as it caused a lot of resentment in the Confucian community. After his son warned him about the dangers of suppressing Confucianism, Qin Shihuang sent him into exhile, further proof that the first emperor was quite ruthless toward ideas he did not like.

From a long-term perspective, the burning of the books did not have a huge impact, because at the time most books were orally transmitted. The impact has also been mitigated by books that have been dug up in recent years. However, during the Qin dynasty, it was disastrous for the newly-founded empire. Not only did it create fear within the scholars and the educated community, but also it restricted intellectual freedom, fomenting resentment.

2. Embarking on Projects of Immense Scale and Human Costs

The emperor's other major fault lay in the inhumane conditions on his huge construction projects, such as the Great Wall, the canal, the Terracotta Army, and other infrastructure projects. Harshness was expected under legalist rule, and as a result, the people suffered immensely. Countless died in these construction projects, and the resentment toward the Qin rulers grew larger and larger. The harsh conditions of construction combined with the strict Qin laws meant that even the smallest mistakes and crimes would get punished unreasonably. All of these faults of Qin Shihuang and his first dynasty eventually caused the final collapse of the short-lived dynasty.

The Final Analysis

Did Qin Shihuang’s achievements outweigh his faults? Personally, I would say yes. He did more good than harm. Fundamentally, he established a governance model that successive dynasties emulated throughout the rest of Chinese history. He had to do the unpopular work of getting everything in place for an empire, which later emperors were faced with the task maintaining, rather than creating. The Han dynasty simply re-arranged a few things to correct Qin Shihuang’s mistakes and took off from where the Qin ended, wisely learning from its mistakes. Legalism was still infused into the Chinese administrative and legal system, except that later dynasties used a Confucian coating to make it more pleasant to the masses. This made it more sustainable and functional in the long term.

Admittedly, Qin Shihuang was not a benevolent figure and his actions were certainly harsh. Still, his achievements were very important and significant to the development of Chinese culture and history, despite the short-lived dynasty. Therefore, on a long term scale, Qin Shihuang’s achievements outweigh his faults.

Comments

DTXSOUL on August 17, 2020:

Wow he really hasn't came back. Welp, see you guys in a year or two... When I want another influx of nostalgia. (=

i am studding for social studies person on August 03, 2020:

helped me to learn alottttttttttt

sick oh on June 11, 2020:

thanks that was so lkind of you all

thata was osoooooo sick bro mannnn love it

just love it post more such good drawring toooooo

Alfie on June 11, 2020:

This was an amazing piecw of rirint

this i your mom on May 29, 2020:

gosh darn it chatting on homework again

juice wrld (yes im alive) on May 28, 2020:

yes im alive and in the bahamas

hui on May 01, 2020:

thank you

DON'T TOUCH MY COOKIES OR MY FOOD on March 19, 2020:

Thanks that helped me a lot and like a lot of people this was for my Assessment hope I do well. Thank you again it was very helpful

Boomer on March 11, 2020:

Very good helped me on social studies assignment

nuggets r good on March 05, 2020:

i dont want google homes but it pops up

your mum on March 03, 2020:

thanks for doing my school work lol

cdffbhb on February 11, 2020:

it helped in a debate evean though i just starred at it did no read of it

koolman on February 07, 2020:

Nice it's pretty useful

SUPREM SPICE on February 05, 2020:

thanks bro this is pretty spicy info, now I'm gonna use for my project. Stay funky fresh my bro.

gogo on December 16, 2019:

this did nothing to help me

lkjhgtf on December 13, 2019:

thanks

EE on December 09, 2019:

nice web

Name . on November 19, 2019:

This was very helpful I needed this for my biography

Sophia on November 17, 2019:

thank you so much! I had to write an essay in one day and this was a big help.

Olive on November 11, 2019:

that's very helpful

jeff on October 21, 2019:

so cool

Hugh Jass on October 15, 2019:

wow thank you sooo much dab

O heyyy on October 14, 2019:

I need friends

Hillbilly Joe on September 26, 2019:

How do i open a door?

alex brawley on September 18, 2019:

red bin

choppy on September 12, 2019:

theres my answers to my project

Afet2 on September 10, 2019:

Very useful! I used these in Chinese class!

JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJare you sure about that on August 22, 2019:

noice work imma die now.

cooper on July 24, 2019:

thanks it helped a ton :)

good job

jayda white on July 24, 2019:

i like cheese

Noice on July 22, 2019:

Noice

j on June 24, 2019:

thanks this helped me for my school assignment

poooo on June 15, 2019:

good

your boi on June 13, 2019:

pretty good bye it has some down sides jk

Yeetus on June 11, 2019:

Thx for the website even though it didn't answer my question;)

Enraged G4m3r on June 05, 2019:

thanks bro

lol on May 21, 2019:

thanks

YOUR WORST NIGHT BUG on May 19, 2019:

there are a lot of thoughts

Hi on May 06, 2019:

There are too many thoughts, try to use less

Dontonio on May 06, 2019:

Thx dude It helped me a lot suhhhhhh duude

hi on April 29, 2019:

nice

hi there on April 23, 2019:

good job my grade is up

unknown on April 16, 2019:

thanks

Unknown on April 14, 2019:

Thanks for most your ideas, it really helped me, keep it up :D

moonlightbae on April 10, 2019:

i couldnt find all my answers but i like this website its rlly useful:)

Hi friends on April 02, 2019:

Hi i really like the website but i diddnt answer my question

Kat on March 20, 2019:

thank u so much I woud't been able to complete my assignment with out this website keep up the good work

GODICA on March 20, 2019:

OMG SAME this helped me so much you can not beliieve how many facts i got while working on my assignment and i think i got an A we shall see please pray for me im desperate and also wish me good luck as i love this boy names Daid and hes datting someone so please help me and pray fo me tank yall love yall wish me good luck so we can get mearried nd have champion kids.

Shhh.. on March 15, 2019:

This was an amazing article! It helped a lot during a assignment. ( I did not copy your work ) :D

Unknown on March 12, 2019:

this was a good article!!!!❤

not telling on March 12, 2019:

nice

amyus on December 14, 2018:

i like it

hi how are ya on December 11, 2018:

good job.

Galectro the youtuber on December 07, 2018:

this website has helped me a lot for my essay if your looking for good stuff you found it and also dont forget to dab on the haters by lololololol

it was ok on November 07, 2018:

this was a reasonable website with ok information but it was very amature and set out horribly

Help me learn on November 04, 2018:

This website was very helpful and gave me some good information on Qin Shi Huang- as this is a school project I need to learn about, very good information that was helpful and truthful

ok on October 25, 2018:

Uniting China

Establishing the Qin dynasty

Reinforcing legalism within the Chinese administrative system

Restructuring political divisions to form a more coherent state

Harmonising measurement units to allow for consistent, state-wide economic development

Standardising the different Chinese scripts

Building the Great Wall to protect the northern borders

Constructing the Lingqu canal in the south to connect the major waterways and prevent flooding

Building the overall infrastructure for national economic development

Building the impressive Terracotta Army.

Here I will elaborate on what I consider to be the emperor's top five achievements.

1. Unifying China

Qin Shihuan conquered all of the states in China, ending the Warring States period.

Qin Shihuan conquered all of the states in China, ending the Warring States period.

The most important achievement under Qin Shihuang is the unification of China. After the Qin state conquered all others, ending the Warring States period, Qin Shihuang declared himself the first emperor—until that point, there had only been kings. With that, he founded the first Chinese dynasty. He continued to expand the Qin dynasty after unifying China, going as far south as Vietnam. This laid a solid foundation for future Chinese dynasties until the collapse of the Qing dynasty in the early 1900s.

The second most important of his achievements was the reinforcement of legalism within the Chinese administrative systems. The impact of this achievement far outlasted the Qin dynasty, and survives even under the current Communist rule.

Legalism is a Chinese philosophy best captured in The Book of Lord Shang. It assumes that people are essentially bad and that the only way to maintain public order is through strict laws and severe penalties. It had a great influence on the operation of the Qin dynasty.

Another important change was that meritocracy was valued over aristocracy within the government. The high officials and generals could be anybody who had the skill and the competence for those posts, and only the ruler of the state derived his privilege from birthright. This had a fundamental impact on future Chinese dynasties, in which examinations were introduced to promote people into government capacities, as opposed to inheriting the positions, as had been done in the past.

Qin Shihuang restructured China into military districts so that states would not fall into war once more. The military was so important to him that he built the Terracotta Army to aid him in the afterlife.

Qin Shihuang restructured China into military districts so that states would not fall into war once more. The military was so important to him that he built the Terracotta Army to aid him in the afterlife.

Qin Shihuang's third most important achievement was reforming the political arrangements to ensure China would not fall again into the divisive conflict of the Warring States period. To form a more coherent state, Qin Shihuang created commanderies, or military districts, within all the conquered states. He divided his empire into 36 commanderies in all, each run by a military governor. Within each commandery were a number of counties. The central government’s strong bond with its military commanderies prevented conflicts between states from turning into wars.

Qin Shihuang standarised Chinese scripts, improving internal communication throughout the large country.

Qin Shihuang standarised Chinese scripts, improving internal communication throughout the large country.

The fourth achievement was standardising everything from measurement units to writing scripts.

Economically, commerce was enhanced as currency, weights, roads and cart axle length were standardised. The development of roads and canals also created better connectivity between major trading regions.

Culturally, the writing script was standardised and made official throughout the dynasty. This created better internal communications for the state. All of these changes had very long-lasting impacts on later Chinese dynasties.

5. Building the Great Wall of China

One of Qin Shihuang's achievements was building the Great Wall of China, now considered one of the Seven Wonders of the World.

One of Qin Shihuang's achievements was building the Great Wall of China, now considered one of the Seven Wonders of the World.

Qin Shihuang also built the Great Wall of China to protect the dynasty from raids from the north. The construction of the wall lasted for 2,000 years after he began the project, and spans 13,171 mi (21,196 km) with all of its branches. It is so expansive that US Senator Jake Garn has said he could see the wall from space shuttle orbit. The wall is considered one of the Seven Wonders of the World.

This was not Qin Shihuang's only historic monument; he also built the impressive Terracotta Army in his pursuit of immortality. The army has over 8,000 figures, each personalized with facial details and holding actual weapons. The army was also accompanied by statues of chariots, horses, officials, acrobats, and musicians and was in fact part of an entire necropolis of offices, stables, and halls surrounding Qin Shihuang's mausoleum, built beneath a huge tomb mound. Qin Shihuang's mausoleum is now a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

Both of these constructions withstood the test of time and are still here today, providing great cultural sites for the people of the modern era.

Qin Shihuang's Two Major Faults

Qin Shihuang’s many faults and unattractive features derive in large part from his achievements.

One of his most well-known traits is harshness, which at times was considered despotic. He is said to have maintained strict order over his kingdom, and valued obedience above all. As the first ruler to have united many Warring States and subsequently impose a central government with astonishing alacrity, this trait may seem expected in some ways.

However, historical accounts should be taken with a grain of salt. Our only concrete sources about the Qin dynasty come largely from Han historians. Qin Shihuang's legalism, which believed strict rule was necessary because people inherently could not be trusted to govern themselves, was explicitly opposed to scholars' Confucianism, which believes that humans can and should try to improve themselves.From Qin Shihuang's legalist perspective, these views held by scholars were divisive, and consequently, scholars were persecuted in different ways, as seen below.

Ordinary people resented the Qin dynasty not only because of the emperor's harshness, but also because of legalism itself. While Qin Shihuang can be blamed partially for the faults of legalism, it was seen as the only way to unite the people and maintain order in the short term.

Qin Shihuang is most frequently faulted for the burning of books and burying of scholars. Technically it was not his idea, but that of Li Si to suppress thoughts and unify political and intellectual opinions by destroying books. The burning of books was also motivated by Qin Shihuang's desire to standardise scripts, because it was a method of removing books with non-standard writing. The many different political theories known as the ‘Hundred Schools of Thought’ and many history books were destroyed in the process, with the exception of books on legalism as well as a few on divination, medicine, agriculture, and war.

Historical accounts report that he buried alive between 400 and 700 scholars in the capital after being tricked by two alchemists. He was very concerned with mortality, as shown by his building the Terracotta Army as a monument to himself, and he was always looking for ways to extend his life through supernatural means.

Some of the scholars were also Confucians—despite his first son’s advice to not do so, Qin Shihuang continued to suppress the philosophy. This was perhaps the greatest shock to his dynasty’s foundation, as it caused a lot of resentment in the Confucian community. After his son warned him about the dangers of suppressing Confucianism, Qin Shihuang sent him into exhile, further proof that the first emperor was quite ruthless toward ideas he did not like.

From a long-term perspective,

lemon on October 25, 2018:

will truth come back??

yo on October 15, 2018:

this was very helpful

yo on October 15, 2018:

bad things are right at the top :D

eden on September 04, 2018:

hi guys

gghghghghghghghg on September 03, 2018:

this was really good for my year seven assesment it had all the rese

bigdaddysam on August 28, 2018:

truth you lik touch the little ones

#getroasted

robbie rotten on August 27, 2018:

rip stefan

h on August 21, 2018:

Ummm hi Just wondering when was this published

Keke on August 21, 2018:

Do you love me

John S. Cena on August 13, 2018:

He was neither completely good nor bad

DTXSOUL on August 02, 2018:

actually, I am 53 and have a surgeon's degree with an op 1 (probably much better than yours. My son has been chatting with you he won't be doing that anymore. Also, you should realise if you are a teacher that is I wouldn't say anything about this website. Oh, and one more tip never ask where someone lives on the internet.

Sorry for any inconveniences

Truth on July 23, 2018:

Well that just shows everyone DTXSOUL how sad and lonley you are probaly a 40 year old how lives in his parents house with nothing better to do with there life!

# Get Roasted

DTXSOUl Yes I am still here on July 22, 2018:

URGGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

I an still watching this website.

So Truth go with the agreement

P.s. Just saying I still am going to watch this website every day.

Spoopy Scary Skeletons on July 21, 2018:

This probably will help me with my history assignment.

'3'

Truth on July 16, 2018:

Ha ha I have returned and will not leave until this unless web page is deleted

#Truth is back!

lol on July 15, 2018:

ya where is the bad things he did

poobumwee on July 15, 2018:

all wrong

MR POOPY on July 04, 2018:

where is the bad things????????

hello on July 03, 2018:

hi thanks for putting this up, it helped in my social studies project

Tazmainian on July 02, 2018:

Why do people talk about how great this guy is, but we're not sure if this stuff really happened in this time.

Unknown on July 02, 2018:

Thank this helped for my history assignment but where are the bad things he did????

AzMaN Gamer on June 26, 2018:

Wheres the dot points on all the bad things qin shi did

o.o on June 25, 2018:

Thx

I had to do a oxford history assignment, This really helped.

dumb on June 24, 2018:

coolio

i wonder...... on June 16, 2018:

this website is good

Tarz on June 10, 2018:

I had to do a history Assignment on this guy, it is really helpful. thx dudes :)))))))))))))))))))))

________________________I AM YOUR MUM________ on June 04, 2018:

This is very helpful, i think I would complete my essay with this website.

Steve Marchesky on June 04, 2018:

Bonjour

Steve Marchesky on May 31, 2018:

You'd better

Gypsy Saw on May 30, 2018:

Hi I think it is very helpful maybe you guys just haven’t been looking probably.

big thunder on May 28, 2018:

nice one gary

menai student on May 28, 2018:

thank you for helping me with my assignment, very much needed

Kaitlin on May 25, 2018:

This is very useful for my essay/ assignment for Qin ShiHuang

Gamer Boy on May 24, 2018:

same i respect the truth

Gamer Boy on May 24, 2018:

same i respect the truth

Bello Bella on May 22, 2018:

Hi all

Bello on May 22, 2018:

Thanks this helped me with a big assignment

Hi on May 21, 2018:

Hi,

This website is good

Catlover on May 21, 2018:

I love cats and I hate the truth

Emanual on May 21, 2018:

This is really good. I used it for all my research and my teacher said it was awesome

THE DUCK MAN on May 21, 2018:

This is a really good website for educational purposes also hello!

Lummy on May 17, 2018:

I changed my mind i hate this website

Name on May 15, 2018:

no one missed you Truth, in fact we glad you left but you had to ruin that glory