MacPharlain enjoys reading good books from many genres. His favorite is historical fiction and his favorite author is Patrick O'Brian.
A Jules Verne Mystery
The Mysterious Island is an exciting tale of mystery and adventure as a group of castaways struggle to overcome the elements and survive on an uncharted island. The novel was written by Jules Verne in 1874. This is an unusual book for Verne because it's more mystery than science fiction.
One thing that was very clear while reading this book is that Jules Verne was a master at telling stories.
Note: This review is of the 2001 English translation by Jordan Stump. Other translations may have differences in wording and names.
"This is the tale of the castaways..."
It's March 1865, the final days of the American Civil War, and five prisoners of war are held captive in Richmond. Desperate to leave the city, they make a daring escape in a hot air balloon during a terrible storm. Carried by the storm's winds for four days, the balloon crashes near an island in the South Pacific.
The castaways are stranded on this unknown shore with nothing but the clothes on their backs and each other. Fortunately, the island is rich in natural resources they'll need to survive. They name the island after President Lincoln and make it their home until they can find a way off. The castaways even consider themselves colonists who will claim the island for the United States and plan to return to it if they ever get home.
As time goes on, the colonists become aware of strange happenings that they cannot explain. Most of these are considered to be the work of Providence. Eventually, they begin to realize that they're not alone on the island.
Thoughts About The Book
"...they're here for a long long time."
Reading this book is like playing a game of Civilization in your head. The colonists start with nothing and then steadily work their way up the technology tree... pottery, iron, chemistry, gunpowder, etc.
It's an interesting story even though the characters were almost too capable in their skills and got along so well. Verne came really close to crossing the believability line there, and it was amusing at times. A couple of the projects they undertake seemed over the top and unnecessary but paid off in the end. The amount of scientific detail was about right for me. The chemistry parts were dry, but chemistry was never my favorite class.
I enjoyed following the colonists as they explored the island and developed their new home. The mystery was engaging, and the action picked up going into the book's last third.
The ending was good but disappointing. It explained the sources of all the mysteries but gave little info on how they happened. It also breezed through the final fate of the colonists. Given some of the lengthy scientific explanations earlier in the book, I expected more detail. Instead, Verne flies through the last five chapters like he's in a hurry to catch a hot air balloon. It really needed more pages.
A strange thing about reading the book was that I found myself humming the tune to Gilligan's Island a lot when I wasn't reading it. I'd think of the book, and that tune popped into my head.
This book was written in French over 100 years ago, so I expected the writing style to be different. The most noticeable thing is that Verne hypes up his characters in very dramatic terms. They appear almost superhuman in their personality traits and abilities. Some descriptions are clearly exaggerated beyond belief...the background on Cyrus Smith states that he was a "participant in every battle of" the Civil War. Every single battle?
I don't know if this was common in 19th-century writing or was one of Verne's traits or something lost in translation, but the exclamation point is used heavily. Very heavily... in places you wouldn't expect. "'Yes!' he murmured." What? How do you exclaim something said in a murmur? You get used to it after a while, and it almost becomes a running joke.
Verne has a very effective narrative style. He engages the reader directly with questions and creates a sense of conversation...like he's sitting across from you telling the tale.
This version of the book also includes the illustrations (over 70) from the original publishings. They're a good supplement to the mental picture you paint of the colonists and their surroundings. The most helpful is the map of Lincoln Island at the front of the book.
Each chapter heading is a list of highlights of what will happen during the chapter. I've never seen this done before. It gives away pieces of the story, so I ignored them after the third or fourth chapter.
What I Liked About The Mysterious Island
- Masterful storytelling kept my attention and interest throughout the book.
- It was fun to ponder what life would be like stuck on an uncharted island. What decisions would I make at each point in the story? Would I know how to make pottery from scratch? Or even think to try?
- Verne wrote the characters with a very positive and confident yet humble attitude that is inspiring and refreshing.
- Arrr! There be pirates in this story!
Verne is known for his science fiction writing and prediction of future uses for technology. This book has a lot of science, but it's mostly stuff that would have been known in the 19th century.
About halfway through the book, Verne has the colonists discussing the world eventually exhausting its supply of coal to power modern industry and transportation. Cyrus Smith predicts that "water is the coal of the future" and will be used to power everything. Specifically by using electricity to break water down into its component elements...hydrogen and oxygen, which are then used to provide power. He's basically talking about using electrolysis to fuel a hydrogen fuel cell.
Beware of Spoilers!
Don't read the Introduction by Caleb Carr before reading the story. It gives away the biggest mystery of the island. The bio of Jules Verne at the start of the book also gives it away and should be avoided until you've read the book.
I don't know why the publishers opted to spoil the surprise for readers. The piece by Carr could have been moved to the end of the book, and they only need to strike one sentence from the Verne bio. They probably assumed everyone is familiar with the story, but that's a poor assumption to make. When the title of the book is The Mysterious Island, it's a bad idea to disclose the key piece of that mystery before the reader actually reads the story.
Unfortunately, I read a summary of the book which gave this away before I read the book. The book was still worth reading but would have been fun to read without that knowledge.
The Translator's Notes by Jordan Stump are safe and kinda interesting to read.
If you don't plan to read the book and want to know the mystery, you can check out Wikipedia's summary.
My Rating of The Mysterious Island
I liked this book a lot. The writing style was a little distracting at first, but the quality of the story quickly took over.
Comparison to the Survivors of Oceanic 815 on Lost
The colonists of Lincoln Island took much more initiative to understand their surroundings and control their destiny than the Oceanic 815 survivors. This could be because they weren't expecting a rescue party to arrive any day like the Losties were. It could also have to do with the time period...people were more self-reliant back in the 19th century.
- Guys, where are we? - Within their first week on Lincoln Island, the colonists climbed to the island's highest peak to get the lay of the land, look for other inhabitants and determine if any other island was nearby. The Losties still haven't mapped out their island completely (Sayid did try to walk all the way around once), and none of them knew there was another island until the end of Season 3.
- Changes in latitude - The colonists figured out their approximate latitude/longitude coordinates using no instruments. The Losties have never attempted this...maybe because they assume they went down in the Pacific.
- Changes in attitude - The colonists think of themselves as...colonists. Of course, they want to get home, but they're determined to make the island their new home until they figure a way off. The Losties are content to chill on the beach and wait to be rescued most of the time.
- Just do it - Lincoln Island offered nearly every raw material the colonists needed. They did some amazing things with that: they built an iron forge, made bricks, produced nitroglycerin, grew crops and even built a telegraph line! The Losties built a few wooden shelters on the beach, Michael built a boat, and Sun planted a garden, but the Losties haven't built much else.
- Teamwork - The Lincoln Island colonists have a lot of respect for one another and very few disagreements. There are some good relationships among the Losties, but there's also a lot of drama: arguments, gun pointing, distrust, stealing, etc.
Now it's your turn...what did you think of The Mysterious Island? Is this your favorite Jules Verne novel? What connections do you see with the TV show Lost?
Please leave a comment below.
Your Review of "The Mysterious Island"
Oliver U on November 08, 2019:
Perfect review. It captures the idea of the book but doesn't reveal to many details
Alan S on September 13, 2018:
Arshii on August 05, 2018:
Arshii on August 05, 2018:
It was a amazing story. I really like Jules Verne novels. It gives inspiration as well as it made my interest in this novel so fast. As it was a fabulous and marvellous novel. I am really speechless about this novel. The best part of this novel was beware of spoilers. It was really a good novel for a new generation. It make interest so fast in children. As my parents read this book so many times and appreciate it.
Padmashree on July 31, 2017:
This book is so interesting and enjoyable.
Charu Bhatnagar from India on October 14, 2016:
I haven't read this book till now though heard a lot about. your review is so good , balanced. Fabulous job. It also made me curious enough so I may definitely read this story in future. Have to add, I have not red other Jules Verne books either till now.
MJ Martin aka Ruby H Rose from Washington State on June 28, 2012:
Great book, like it better than the show. His books and your review, very intriguing.
natashaely on June 19, 2012:
Added this and your other revies to my online library as you have a wonderful way of writing and I have started reading this on your recommendation. A wonderful page as are your other reviews.
Millionairemomma on June 16, 2012:
Liked the book but didn't watch the tv show. Your review was excellent.
nickupton lm on April 19, 2012:
Great book review. I recently bought this book because I have enjoyed other Jules Verne stories. After reading this review of The Mysterious island this will definitely be the next book I read.
Fox Music on April 05, 2012:
Thank You for this Great Lens (book review) about the book "The Mysterious Island" by Jules Verne
anonymous on March 20, 2012:
I just re-read The Mysterious Island, and it wasn't as much fun as when I was a kid but it was still a good read. I'm surprised by your character poll... the engineer is really Cyrus Smith in your version? Cyrus Harding in the two or three different copies I've read. And Herbert instead of Harbert for the boy. What an odd thing to change.
SayGuddaycom on January 26, 2012:
Great book and Ray harryhausen didn't do bad with it either.
christopherwell on October 10, 2011:
This is one of those I'd only heard about before. I'm intrigued!
bhavesh lm on September 26, 2011:
I read the book first as a 10-year old. It was a translation in my native language. I was enraptured by it. The feeling of adventure it inspired in me is indescribable, even today. There was only one problem. I had borrowed the book - the only available - from the local library which had the first 10 pages missing. So I never knew how exactly the castaways got on the island. I recently read it again, mainly for those first 10 pages and hoping that I would be able to relive the experience. It was a bit of a let-down, perhaps because I have become too grown now to appreciate the simplicity of an adventure. I would still give it 5 stars though, for the memories and feeling of adventure it brought to my life. Thanks for doing this review!
JeanJohnson LM on September 20, 2011:
My husband is halfway through this book and he enjoys it very much.
franstan lm on July 29, 2011:
anonymous on July 19, 2011:
Read this book first when I was 13, and have reread it from time to time over the years and just recently again....now 51 and realized I might be able to find a map of the island online to better track the castaways (our settlers in their own vernacular) adventures....and successfully did so on Wiki no less, then stumbling across this site! Pleased to see so many followers. Excellent story and great characters exhibiting the best of humanity and perseverance in the face of great challenges both physical and mental. One of Jule's Vernes best novels!
photofk3 on January 13, 2011:
Myself read this book... excellent!
sciencefictionn on November 03, 2009:
I never read this books but it looks nice like the others novels by Verne. An intriguing lens, excellent job. 5*
Rusty Quill on October 24, 2008:
Well done and another mighty fine addition to Review Central!
Linda Jo Martin from Post Falls, Idaho, USA on July 20, 2008:
I haven't read this book but now I want to. I like the way you put your book review together. I'm lensrolling this to my lens, "Ten Must-Read Classics of Great Literature".
ElizabethJeanAl on June 17, 2008:
5* & Lensroll to The Weekend Reader
Arizona-Snow on June 13, 2008:
I haven't really read any Jules Verne books and I don't watch Lost... but I can say that this is an excellent lens - keep up the good work!