13 Worst Man-Made Environmental Disasters in American History
These disasters have altered the national psyche regarding ecological concerns
Man-made disasters will always be with us, and the United States has had its share of those. Many resulted in no injuries or deaths, though others certainly did, their toll considerable or even impossible to calculate. But all have had a profound effect on the minds of many people regarding environmental issues.
Please note that acts of war or terrorism do not quality for this list. Those disasters were intentional, not accidental.
So, let’s begin the countdown!
13. Cattlegate PBB Contamination
In the state of Michigan in the 1973, instead of a nutritional supplement, polybrominated biphenyls (PBB) was accidentally fed to 1.5 million chickens, 30,000 cattle and other livestock. PBB is an industrial chemical frequently used as a flame retardant for plastics used in the manufacture of electrical appliances, textiles, televisions, computers and plastic foams. Studies show that exposure to PBB in humans can cause serious health problems including skin disorders, nervous and immune system effects, as well as deleterious effects on the liver, kidney and thyroid gland; it may also cause malignancies, particularly breast cancer in women, according to the International Agency for the Research of Cancer.
Six to eight million Michigan residents may have been exposed to PBB by eating the contaminated meat, milk or eggs before it was removed from the market one year after the accidental feeding. The resulting scandal, sometimes referred to as Cattlegate, has remained a worrisome environmental issue ever since. In 2004, studies by the Center for Disease Control (CDC) discovered that Michigan residents have elevated levels of PBB in their blood. Unfortunately, PBB can linger in the human body for years or even decades.
A registry of 7,500 people exposed to PBB—either by producing it, using it or eating it—is kept so that the long-term effects of PBB contamination can be documented. Unfortunately, researchers say that PBB may be transmitted by DNA through many generations, so the scientific investigation of PBB contamination, particularly in Michigan, may continue for quite some time.
12. Bunker Hill Mine
Closed since the 1980s because of environmental concerns, the Bunker Hill Mine, located in the Silver Valley of northern Idaho, may soon reopen after decades of cleanup. At one time, the US Geological Survey estimated that Silver Valley mines, of which the Bunker Hill Mine is the major extractor, deposited more than 880,000 thousand tons of lead into the area’s waterways between 1884 to 1967. And over the life of the Bunker Hill Mine, estimates are that it dumped 75 million tons of toxic sludge, containing lead, zinc, arsenic and cadmium, into Lake Coeur d’Alene, making the water toxic to animals and humans.
In 1983, the EPA declared the Bunker Hill Mine and smelter complex a Superfund site, the nation’s second largest, actually. Then the EPA moved to the site and began cleanup operations, which cost $900 million. Unfortunately, many people think the site is still leaking heavy metals and other toxic substances into nearby lakes, streams and rivers.
“This watershed needs time to heal, and billions of dollars of remedial cleanup, to become a functioning ecosystem again,” says Phil Cernera, an environmental scientist and local Native American.
But the Bunker Hill Mine may soon reopen, now that the EPA thinks the mine and smelter have been sufficiently cleaned up. By the way, there are other mining operations in the Silver Valley.
11. Atomic Homefront
The aforementioned name pertains to an HBO documentary entitled Atomic Homefront (2017). The film tells the story of scores of people who reside in two North St. Louis suburbs, near which radioactive waste – uranium, thorium and radium – was buried in a landfill in the 1940s. (This nuclear material was produced for the Manhattan Project during World War Two.) Residents in these towns claim that because of this contamination many people in the area have contracted cancer, autoimmune disorders and suffered birth defects.
Also, in 1973, in nearby Bridgeton, Missouri, 47,000 tons of nuclear waste was illegally dumped in the West Lake landfill. Eventually, in 1990, this area became an Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Superfund site. Moreover, in recent years, an uncontrolled, underground fire has been moving toward this landfill, a potential calamity since the fire could burn the radioactive waste, sending toxic particles airborne, contaminating other local areas, including, perhaps, the nearby Missouri River. Republic Services, which owns the West Lake landfill, claims that the toxic waste is maintained in “a safe and managed state.”
Many residents think that before they moved into this area, they were not told about the buried radioactive material. Therefore, they want this contamination removed, or the federal and state governments should pay to relocate them.
10. Three-Mile Island Nuclear Accident
In March 1979, one of three nuclear reactors at the Three-Mile Island power plant in Pennsylvania nearly melted down, a catastrophe which could have vented massive amounts of radioactivity into the atmosphere. The trouble started when a valve stuck open, allowing large amounts of nuclear reactor coolant to escape, which raised the temperature of the nuclear reactor. Some human error added to the trouble, but very little radioactivity was leaked or vented into the environment. Nobody got sick – nobody died.
Nevertheless, the nuclear power industry in the U.S. took a big hit in the public relations department, a downturn from which it has never recovered. Since the Three Mile Island disaster, few nuclear power plants have been built in the U.S. and some of those operating have been removed. Moreover, since the nuclear emergencies at the Chernobyl Meltdown in 1986 and at the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant in March 2011, nuclear power around the world is now seen as a potentially dangerous means of generating power. Concerns about nuclear proliferation and terrorism have increased the controversy as well.
9. Middle West Dust Bowl (Dirty Thirties)
Times were hard during the Great Depression of the 1930s, and they got much worse for people living in the Middle West, when vast dust clouds roiled over thousands of the square miles of the U.S., at times reaching as far east as New York City. The cause was drought and soil erosion on a massive scale in the Great Plains of the U.S. and Canada. Farmers, some of whom knowing little or nothing about the ecology of the Plains, used tractors to till deeply into the prairie grass, exposing the moist earth to wind and sun, a farming technique which led to disaster. The topsoil simply blew away, leaving nothing fertile to grow crops.
This resultant Dust Bowl, as it became labeled, affected over one million acres of land. When thousands of people in places such as Oklahoma and Texas could no longer grow food, they moved west to states such as California, a story as dramatized in such novels as John Steinbeck’s Grapes of Wrath and Of Mice and Men.
8. Mississippi Delta Dead Zone
Since the bad old days of the Dust Bowl, farmers in the Middle West have learned how to effectively till the soil without causing vast dust clouds, but now another problem has presented itself: Eutrophication. The chemical fertilizers many farmers now use pump vast amounts of nitrogen and phosphates into rivers such as the Mississippi, creating hypoxic areas known as dead zones. Algae proliferate in such areas, killing fish and other aquatic life. In the Mississippi Delta region of the Gulf of Mexico, this monstrous, suffocating discharge of chemicals and the resultant algal blooms cover some six to eight thousand square miles (the size of some states in the eastern U.S).
Scientists at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the Environmental Protection Agency have hoped to reduce the size of this dead zone to about 2,000 square miles, but this hasn’t happened. The use of chemical fertilizers to produce corn and soy beans is the biggest problem in this regard, so unless American farmers grow considerably less and/or convert to organic farming, the Mississippi Delta Dead Zone will probably get larger in the coming years and decades.
7. Exxon Valdez Oil Spill
In March 1989, the Exxon Valdez, a massive oil tanker, collided with a reef in Prince William Sound, a pristine inlet in the Alaskan wilderness. The wreck dumped 11 million gallons of crude oil into the ocean, a spill covering over 11,000 square miles of ocean and 1,300 miles of coastline. At the time, it was the largest oil spill in the history of the U.S. But detractors such as the Sierra Club and Greenpeace have said that the estimated spill was much worse – 25 to 32 million gallons. Reportedly a drunken captain caused the disaster, but he turned out to be a scapegoat. The real cause was that the ship’s radar system hadn’t been properly maintained and wasn’t even activated during the time of the wreck.
Since the spill happened in a remote area – no roads led to this faraway place – cleanup was a nightmare upon a nightmare. Much of the solvents and dispersants used in the cleanup turned out to be toxic and mechanically cleaning up the spilled oil was never a practical solution in such a fragile, marine environment. Countless thousands of wild animals died in the spill and the seafood industry in the region collapsed. Moreover, estimates suggest that only about 10 per cent of the oil was ever recovered, and to this day much oil remains in the environment of Prince William Sound.
6. Ringwood Mines Landfill Site
The Ringwood Mines Landfill Site is a 500-acre area located in Ringwood, New Jersey. Owned by the Ford Motor Plant, in the late 1960s to early 1970s, the site was used for waste disposal for its nearby Mahwah, New Jersey automobile assembly plant. This waste was mostly paint sludge, a toxic mix of various industrial chemicals and heavy metals, which polluted the environment to the point that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) designated the area as a Superfund site in need of remediation, which began in 1984. By 2011, over 47,000 tons of contaminated earth was removed from the site.
Compounding the problem, many people still reside in this woodsy rural area, namely the Ramapough Mountain Indians, a tribe of about 5,000 folks. These people claim that the toxic waste in the area has sickened and killed them, but proving scientific cause and effect in the legal arena has been difficult. An HBO production titled Mann V. Ford (2011) chronicles the plight of the Ramapough people, who claim they have seen scores of their people die from cancer. According to the documentary, the plaintiffs eventually settled out of court with the Ford Motor Company, but for only thousands of dollars per plaintiff.
5. Picher Lead Contamination
Since 1913, Picher, Oklahoma was one of the biggest mining towns in the country. Lead and zinc were mined there, 20 billion dollars worth from 1917 to 1947. Thousands of people worked in the mines and support services, so times were good for lots of folks. But all the while, toxic waste piled up in Picher, and the waterways in the area turned reddish brown. In 1996, investigators discovered that 34 per cent of the children in Picher had lead poisoning, mainly because lead had contaminated the ground water. Eventually Picher and other nearby communities became part of the Tar Creek Superfund site.
Many buildings and homes in the Pitcher area became seriously undermined by decades of digging, and the town became a very dangerous and unhealthy place to live. In 2009, the state of Oklahoma "dis-incorporated" the town of Picher and, with the help of federal money, people began moving away. Now Picher is a ghost town and considered one of the most toxic places in the U.S.
4. Love Canal
The story of Love Canal has become an iconic tale of the people vs. corporate interests. In the early decades of the 1900s, the Hooker Chemical Company (now Occidental Petroleum) buried 21,000 tons of toxic waste in the Love Canal section of Niagara Falls, New York. (Love Canal had once been the site of a canal excavation project to connect the city to the Niagara River.) In 1953, Hooker sold the land to the city of Niagara Falls for $1, while telling the city about the presence of toxic waste, and then housing and a school were eventually built on the site.
Then, in the 1970s, people in the Love Canal area began reporting health problems and then various scientific investigations began. Among other toxic substances, dioxin and benzene were found in parts per billion (parts per trillion are considered dangerous for dioxin.) By 1978, the story of Love Canal had become a national media event. At one point, President Carter declared Love Canal a disaster site and federal money was given to the residents to help them relocate. In 1995, the EPA sued Occidental Petroleum and forced the company to pay $129 million to help pay for cleanup of the site. Astonishingly, some people still live in the Love Canal area!
3. Libby Asbestos Contamination
Beginning in the 1920s, a mine in Libby, Montana produced most of the world’s supply of vermiculite, a mineral used to make insulation in homes and businesses. Vermiculite in its impure form may contain asbestos, a known carcinogen. In 1990, the federal government investigated the mine and the W.R. Grace Company, which owns it, eventually closed the operation. Various sources, such as the Seattle Post-Intelligencer, have claimed that the asbestos at the mining site has given numerous people serious health problems and that over 400 people have died from diseases caused by exposure to the asbestos.
Since then, the EPA has declared the area a Superfund site and spent millions of dollars on cleanup; it also fined the W.R. Grace Company, hoping to reimbursement some of the money. The U.S. government is also considering filing criminal charges, alleging that the W.R. Grace Company did not inform its employees of the dangers of mining vermiculite. The cleanup of this toxic site - perhaps the worst in the history of the U.S – as well as the litigation, potential and otherwise, continues to this day.
2. Deepwater Horizon Oil Gusher
In April 2010, an explosion rocked the Deepwater Horizon oil rig in the Gulf of Mexico. The rig subsequently sank into the Gulf, killing 11 people. No longer sealed at the seafloor, the damaged rig leaked oil into ocean - and it gushed for 87 days, spilling an estimated 210 million gallons of crude oil into the sea. Oil dispersant was used to spread the oil around, but it turned out to be more toxic than the crude oil. The leak was finally tapped, but may still leak some, who knows? This deluge of oil is considered the worst accidental marine oil spill in the history of petroleum exploration.
British Petroleum or BP, the owner of the rig, was found to be criminally responsible for the disaster. It was convicted of many felonies and misdemeanors, and has paid dearly for this environmental catastrophe, as much as $42 billion at last count. Moreover, the injuries and death to sea life was massive and incalculable, and fishing interests in the Gulf were severely damaged. Moreover, much crude oil is still present in the ecosystem of the area and will be for many years.
1. Nuclear Weapons Detonations at the Nevada Test Site
After the end of World War Two, the U.S. and the Soviet Union entered a period known as the Cold War, a time when both sides tested numerous nuclear devices – both below ground and above. At first, the U.S. exploded its bombs in the South Pacific, and then in January 1951 they began nuclear testing at the Nevada Test Site in southern Nevada. At times, the mushroom clouds from these detonations could be seen in the city of Las Vegas, only 65 miles from the site. Moreover, parts of Nevada, Arizona and Utah had radioactive fallout sprinkled upon its residents for years during the atmospheric tests.
But the town of St. George in Utah may have gotten the worst of the fallout, because it was downwind of the test site. In fact, a John Wayne movie, The Conqueror, was filmed around St. George when a bomb nicknamed “Dirty Harry” was exploded, and afterwards the film's cast and crew experienced an unusually high rate of cancer.
Furthermore, deaths from various forms of cancer increased in the test site area from the middle 1950s into the 1980s. After testing at the site ended in 1992, the Department of Energy estimated that 300 megacuries of radioactivity remain at the site, making it the most radioactive place in the U.S. Nevertheless, public tours are allowed here, though you have to wonder why anybody would want to visit such a terrible place!
Please leave a comment.
Questions & Answers
Why isn't the PBB poisoning of Michigan in the 1970s included on this list of worst man-made environmental disasters?
After doing some research on this disaster I will add it to this list ASAP!Helpful 1
© 2014 Kelley Marks