Bumble Bee Behavior: Surprising Capabilities of Small Brains
Some Unexpected Discoveries
Like all insects, bumble bees have small brains with a much simpler appearance than a human's. Researchers have discovered that despite these facts the insects have some surprising mental abilities. Experimental evidence indicates that bumble bees have the ability to solve quite complex problems, generally after receiving training by humans or after observing other bees solving the problems. They can pull a ball along a path and into a goal. They can also pull an inaccessible disk towards them with a string. The insects learn from one another and may have a rudimentary culture. They may even experience optimism.
The terms bumble bee (or bumblebee), humble bee (or humblebee), and dumbledore are all names for the same insect. The last name is rarely used today and the second name is uncommon. Bumble, humble, and dumble all refer to the humming, buzzing, or droning sound made by a bee in flight.
Bumble bees belong to the genus Bombus. There are around 250 species in the genus. Many are social insects, but some are solitary. Most live in the northern hemisphere. A few species inhabit South America, however, and some species have been introduced to New Zealand and Tasmania.
Bumble bees often have stout bodies. They also have a furry appearance, which endears them to some people. They can sting and may do so defensively, but I find them much less bothersome than the yellow jacket wasps in my area. I've never been stung by a bumble bee, but I have been stung by a wasp.
The species used in the studies described in this article was the buff-tailed bumble bee, or Bombus terrestris. It's one of the most common bumble bees in Europe.
The Life Cycle of the Colony
In early spring the queen bee emerges from her underground location, where she has been hibernating during the winter. She visits the first flowers of the year to feed on nectar and pollen. Once she has built up enough strength, she establishes a nest. The nest may be located in an old rodent burrow or in a location above ground, such as in a patch of dead grass.
The queen lays eggs that become females known as workers. The workers take care of the nest and its inhabitants and gather nectar and pollen for the colony. They are not sterile and lay eggs under certain conditions. These are the animals that are used in behavior experiments.
Near the end of summer, drones (the males) are born from unfertilized eggs and new queens are produced from larvae that are fed a special diet. The drones and new queens leave the colony to find mates. The old queen and her workers die before winter, as do the drones. Only the new queens survive to start another colony in the following year.
In the first part of the twentieth century, the buff-tailed bumble bee was known as the large earth humble bee and the buff-tailed humble bee.
Researchers at the Queen Mary University of London have performed several interesting experiments related to the learning capabilities of bumble bees. In 2017, they studied a behavior that they call bee soccer.
Some bees in a group were trained to pull a small wooden ball along a pathway and into a marked circle (the "goal post"). As soon as a bee scored a goal, the experimenter placed a drop of sucrose in the circle for the bee to drink. The training period took around five hours, not including rest times for the insects. Training techniques included moving the ball in the correct direction with a fake bee attached to a stick and via a moving magnet under the surface of the "soccer field".
Untrained bees who watched a trained soccer player needed to see only three goals before they could perform the task themselves. The untrained insects reached the goal "almost every time" after their observations, according to the Nature article referenced below. Bees with no training and no opportunity to watch experienced insects scored a goal about 30% of the time.
Bumble Bees Playing Soccer
These miniature brains can accomplish a lot more than we thought.— Clint Perry, Queen Mary University of London
Pulling a String to Get a Reward
In an experiment described in 2016, the researchers discovered that bumble bees can also learn to pull a string to get a reward. The experimental setup was as follows.
- Three blue disks containing a well with a sucrose (table sugar) solution inside were placed in a row.
- The disks were covered by a plexiglass table that was raised slightly off the floor. The gap between the table and the floor was too shallow for the bees, so they were unable to reach the disk and its sucrose.
- A piece of string was connected to each disk and ran under the table to the outside world. Pulling this string brought the disk to the edge of the table and made the well accessible.
Training a Bumble Bee to Pull a String
Some bees were trained to reach and drink the sucrose. At first there was no obstruction between the insects and the disk containing the sucrose solution. The disk was then gradually moved further and further away from the bees until finally the only way to reach it was to pull it by the string.
Some bees weren't trained and were immediately presented with the experimental setup described above. Only two of 110 bees pulled the string to reach the disk. Other bees that hadn't been trained watched the trained bees pulling the string and drinking the sucrose solution. As a result, sixty percent of these untrained bees pulled the string on their first exposure to the setup.
Interestingly, even when the first bee who was trained to pull the the string died, the technique continued to be passed from bee to bee through the colony. String-pulling became part of the colony's behavior.
Optimistic Bees (Perhaps): Experimental Setup
It's often hard to know for certain what emotions another person is feeling, let alone members of another species. There is evidence suggesting that bumble bees may experience a sensation akin to optimism, however.
Once again, research into this topic was carried out by scientists at the Queen Mary University of London. The university has a group of scientists who are very interested in bumble bee abilities. The researchers trained twenty-four bees to travel through a metal cylinder and into a closed chamber. The chamber contained four tubes. One of the tubes had either a green or a blue tag. A green-tagged tube contained water. A blue-tagged tube contained a 30% sugar solution. The bees needed to enter a tube to drink the liquid. They learned that the blue-tagged tube was a rewarding place to visit.
The bumble bees that have been studied have trichromatic vision. They see best in the UV, blue, and green regions of the electromagnetic spectrum.
In the next stage of the optimism experiment, the researchers replaced the blue and green-tagged tubes with one containing a tag of an intermediate and ambiguous color. As the bees entered the metal cylinder on their way to the chamber and its tubes, half of them received a drop of 60% sugar. The other half received nothing.
The researchers found that the bees who had received the sugar gift took less time to enter the ambiguous tube than those who received no gift. This suggested that they might be feeling optimistic about what they would find in the tube.
In order to negate the possibility that "optimistic" bees were reacting faster due to the effect of the sugar on their general physiology instead of on their brain, the researchers treated some of the bees with a dopamine inhibitor. This blocked the reward center in the brain and stopped the bees from displaying optimistic behavior. Dopamine is involved in the reward system in the human brain as well as in the brain of bumble bees.
Intelligence and Learning
The popular press often refers to bumble bee "intelligence" when they discuss the interesting discoveries that are being made about the insects. Scientists are more cautious about using this term. In general, bumble bees must be trained to solve a problem in the lab, although a higher number of bees solve a problem on their own in some situations than in others. It could be argued that the insects must have a certain level of mental development in order to be trainable, however.
Some scientists have pointed out that it's hard to design a suitable intelligence test for animals that have different senses, physical abilities, and lifestyles from humans. Others have noted that we may be biased towards those animals that are most like us when we decide to classify an animal as intelligent. Still, the idea that an insect can exhibit intelligent behavior is controversial.
There is less controversy about the discovery that bumble bees can learn and pass on their knowledge to their companions. The transfer of skills may create a rudimentary culture. It's uncertain how applicable lab discoveries are to the everyday life of bees in the wild, however.
I'm looking forward to seeing what else scientists discover about the capabilities of bumble bee brains and of the brains of other insects. The discoveries so far are very interesting.
- Abilities of Small Brains in Bumble Bees and Other Insects from the BBC or British Broadcasting Corporation (It's important to note whether the writer is talking about bumble bees or honeybees in this article. For example, the writer states that bees can recognize human faces and count. The relevant research was done in honeybees, not bumble bees, however.)
- Bee Soccer from Nature.com
- Social Learning and Cultural Transmission in an Insect from PLOS (an open access and peer reviewed journal)
- Optimistic Behavior in Bumble Bees from sciencemag.org (a publication of AAAS, or the American Academy for the Advancement of Science)
© 2017 Linda Crampton