Calculus Optimization: Cone of Maximal Volume Inscribed in a Sphere
Lots of classical calculus problems involve finding the optimal dimensions of a shape inscribed in a sphere so that the shape has the largest possible volume. One of the easiest examples of such a problem is finding the dimensions of a cylinder inscribed within a sphere. Here we tackle a very similar problem, finding the maximum volume cone that can fit inside a sphere. Though a cone has two independent measurements, base radius and height, the constraint that it must fit inside a unit sphere (sphere of radius 1) lets us transform a two-variable calculus problem into a simpler single-variable calculus problem.
Step 1: Transforming a 2-Variable Equation Into a 1-Variable Equation
The formula for the volume of a cone is V(r, h) = (π/3)hr^2. Here, the function V is a function of r and h. But when a cone must fit exactly inside a unit sphere, we can discover a relation between r and h that allows us to rewrite r as a function of h, or h as a function of r. The figure below shows how we can relate r and h for a cone inscribed in a unit sphere.
When a cone is inscribed in a unit sphere, the relation between h and r is
(h-1)^2 + r^2 = 1
which can be simplified to
h^2 - 2h + 1 + r^2 = 1
h^2 - 2h + r^2 = 0
r^2 = 2h - h^2
r = sqrt(2h - h^2)
Now we can rewrite the cone volume formula solely in terms of h:
V(r, h) = (π/3)hr^2
V(h) = (π/3)h*[sqrt(2h - h^2)]^2
= (π/3)h(2h - h^2)
= (π/3)(2h^2 - h^3)
Step 2: Taking the Derivative, Finding h and r
The last step is to take the derivative of the volume function V(h), set the derivative expression equal to zero, solve for h, and then use our value of h to back solve for r. Doing so gives us
V'(h) = (π/3)(4h - 3h^2)
(π/3)(4h - 3h^2) = 0
4h - 3h^2 = 0
4h = 3h^2
4 = 3h
h = 4/3
So the cone with a maximal volume that can be inscribed within a unit circle has a height of 4/3. To figure out the value of r, we use the expression r = sqrt(2h - h^2) that we found in Step 1. Plugging h = 4/3 into this expression gives us
r = sqrt(8/3 - 16/9)
Finally, we can write the solution as h = 4/3 and r = sqrt(8/9). The volume of this cone works out to be
V = (π/3)(4/3)(sqrt(8/9))^2
The volume of a unit sphere is 4π/3, which means the cone of maximal volume takes up 8/27 or about 29.63% of the unit sphere's volume.
Comparison to the Cylinder Problem
In the closely related problem of a finding a maximal volume cylinder inscribed within a unit sphere, the optimal dimensions turned out to be h = 2/sqrt(3) and r = sqrt(2/3), with a total cylindrical volume of V = 4π/[3*sqrt(3)] ≈ 2.4184.
Solving as a 2-Variable Calculus Problem
Instead of transforming this into a single-variable problem, you can solve it as a 2-variable problem using the technique of Lagrange multipliers. This is a technique covered in multivariable calculus or Calc III. With Lagrange multipliers, we call the constraint equation g(r, h) = r^2 - 2h + h^2 = 0 and solve the system of equations
∂V/∂r = λ*∂g/∂r
∂V/∂h = λ*∂g/∂h
g = 0
which is the system
(2π/3)hr = 2λr
(π/3)r^2 = 2λ(1-h)
r^2 - 2h + h^2 = 0
Since it is a system of non-linear equations, you cannot use matrices to solve it, but instead substitution.
More by this Author
The antiderivatives of sin(x)^3 and cos(x)^3 [also written sin^3 (x) and cos^3 (x)] can be found using a simple trigonometric identity and u-substitution. Some alternative forms of sine cubed and cosine cubed can be...
Formulas for the volume of a trapezoidal pyramid as well as several example problems to solve, with solutions.
Comprehensive illustrated list of names for both flat shapes and solid shapes. Geometry reference for elementary and middle school, as well as home school. Over 60 pictures of geometric shapes.
No comments yet.