My Quest to Make a True-Color Collage of Nine Planets
My photo collage above was inspired by Steven Gildea's "Planetary Suite" oil painting, which thousands of people are sharing on social media (a) without credit and (b) without realizing it's a painting. It's beautiful, but it's not strictly accurate, especially since it was made before we reached Pluto.
So I set out to make a collage of the real thing. This proved much more difficult than I'd anticipated. It turns out that most photos of planets aren't true color!
Spacecraft Can See More Wavelengths Than Superman
You may have seen a collage like this one posted by Business Insider. They're real NASA photos, but they're not necessarily what the human eye would see.
Space probes and telescopes have sensitive cameras that pick up wavelengths beyond the range of human vision. This lets these instruments "see" many details invisible to the human eye, helping to distinguish different kinds of rocks, ices, gases or other materials on the surface.
Most spacecraft can "see" into infrared and/or ultraviolet wavelengths:
False-Color Images: Visible Light Plus Infrared or Ultraviolet
To help us "see" hidden details, scientists convert non-visible wavelengths into colors we can see. Either they'll represent infrared and ultraviolet with bright colors (below right), or they'll convert the image to show colors visible to human eyes (below left).
Martian Surface: Converting Mars Light to Earth Light
The Martian atmosphere is very dusty. Photos taken from the surface of Mars often look like they were taken during a dust storm at sunset.
To overcome this problem, researchers adjust photos from Mars missions using a color calibration patch stuck on the spacecraft. Knowing what that patch looked like before it left Earth helps scientists adjust Mars photos to match Earth lighting. This makes it easier to compare Martian and Earth rocks.
NASA scientist Donald E. Davis, who worked on Mars missions, has a detailed article on the colors of Mars, discussing the hows and whys of color in photos taken by the different rovers and landers.
Ultraviolet and Radar Images
Venus is another planet that's usually shown in false color. In reality, it's covered in a thick layer of cream-colored clouds that are almost featureless. It looks like a pearl.
I've never seen a true-color image of Venus from any spacecraft. Instead, we get false-color photos using infrared or ultraviolet. For radar images, which are essentially elevation maps, the color is simulated, based on surface photos taken by Soviet landers.
So Then How Did I Make That Photo Collage?
It took a lot of hunting, but I finally found true-color, or adjusted to true-color, photos of the most well-known nine planets. (Sorry, Ceres, Eris, Haumea and friends).
Here are the photos I used.
Mercury Adjusted to True Color
The Mercury MESSENGER spacecraft surveyed the planet in 11 different wavelengths, including near-infrared, to bring out color.
Venus via the Image Processing Community
For the past few years, astrophotography enthusiasts like Mattias Malmer have been sifting through old NASA mission files, looking for color data and photos which they can combine and adjust into true-color images.
NASA respects the work of the image processing community, most of whom are professional photographers and/or astronomers. In fact, I first found Malmer's color-adjusted Venus photo in a NASA scientific article.
Here are more true-color image-processed photos of Venus and Mercury.
Realtime Images of Earth From Japan
Japan's new Himawari-8 weather satellite, perched in geosynchronous orbit over the Pacific ocean, takes the highest-resolution true-color photos I've ever seen. The above screencap does not do it justice.
Even Mars Is Tricky
Surprisingly, finding a true-color photo of Mars was my biggest challenge.
First, Mars is not always the same color: it varies due to massive dust storms (Surveyor, Hubble) and/or minute amounts of water ice in the atmosphere (see planetary scientists' comments on this post). Second, we have photos from several decades of spacecraft, some better calibrated than others. Also, the Hubble website sometimes uses the term "true color" loosely to mean "natural color, as opposed to false color like this."
So I scoured various images and had to make a judgement call:
- NASA calls this "true color", a Viking photomosaic projected on an elevation map: butterscotch.
- Here's the STUNNINGLY GORGEOUS Viking photomosaic used in #1, minus elevation data: butterscotch.
- National Geo's award-winning, independently-praised true-color map of Mars, using Mars Global Surveyor data: butterscotch.
- Hubble calls this image "true color": brick red.
- NOT true color, but "stretched" to bring out details: brick red.
I've decided to go with the Mars Global Surveyor images used by National G. That library is maintained/color-calibrated by Malin Space Science Systems, responsible for cameras on most Mars missions for the past 20 years (NASA also tapped MSS to make the Juno camera for its next-generation Jupiter mission).
The Mini-World Brigade
Yes, I know. There's either more or less than nine planets.
For puposes of my collage above, the "dwarf planet" debate is moot: we're not going to have detailed photos of Eris or Pluto's other siblings any time soon. I'll add Ceres when the spacecraft currently orbiting it gets around to sending color photos.
Jupiter Seen by Cassini En Route to Mars
Finally! Here's a straightforward one.
NASA's Cassini spacecraft snapped several beauty shots of the giant planet on the way out to Saturn. Here's another gorgeous Cassini photo of Jupiter showing a little more detail, and one closer still.
Jupiter is a beefy 88,846 miles in diameter, yet its day is less than 10 Earth hours. Its fast rotation causes it to bulge sideways. Jupiter is 11.2 Earths wide but only 10.5 Earths tall, a difference of about 5,764 miles.
Cassini at Saturn: 2004-2015
The Cassini Mission is responsible for a decade plus of amazing science, discovering the rivers and seas of Titan, the giant geysers of Enceladus, and the iconic photo of Earth seen behind the rings of Saturn. Cassina also dropped the first probe to photograph the surface of Titan!
You may have noticed some faint blue-gray stormcloud spots, more visible in the hi-res version of this image. In 2011, Saturn had massive thunderstorms at about that latitude in the northern hemisphere.
Like Jupiter, Saturn is squashed due to its fast rotation; its day is 10.5 Earth hours.
Uranus: Visible Light, Invisible Beauty
Tranquil, isn't it? In infrared, you can see that Uranus has faint smoky rings and wispy clouds.
Once again, this took some work. I knew from the Neptune images that Voyager 2 images tend to be a little over-saturated, making Uranus look like spearamint.
To correct this, I overlaid a lower-resolution, "natural-color" Hubble image of Uranus [NASA/ESA, Erich Karkoschka] and borrowed the Hue. Dr. Erich Karkoschka is one of the foremost atmospheric scientists for Neptune and Uranus, so I'm a little more confident in his "natural color." Also, I compared my result with Björn Jónsson's image processing, and the color is quite close.
ETA: And here's a tiny but uber-cool natural-color photo of Uranus peeping behind Saturn's rings, taken by the Cassini spacecraft.
Neptune: The Blue Maelstrom
When I reached out to Dr. Emily Lakdawalla, planetary scientist and blogger for the Planetary Report, she recommended Neptune image processing by Björn Jónsson. See this post explaining how he combined Voyager 2's high-resolution b&w data with lower-resolution color data to make the beautiful mosaic above.
New Horizons, built 30 years after Voyager, has better low-light optics, so it can see even when the sun is 3 billion miles away.
Like Uranus, Pluto rotates knocked on its side. From New Horizon's perspective, Pluto's north pole is tipped slightly towards us, in that yellowish area near the top of the photo.
- Donald E. Davis: Color in the Solar System
Donald E. Davis, NASA scientist, understands the optics of space probes as well as anyone. I was focusing on colors, but he's fine-tuning albedo, reflectivity of surfaces, which I think my other sources may have missed.
- The Planets in Natural Colors | Planetarium
Madison Planetarium attempts to find true-color photos of the planets. Looks like I'm not the only one struggling. They're going with the redder Mars.
- Collage: "The Not Planets" by Dr. Emily Lakdawalla
I based my collage on Gildea's "Planetary Suite." In fact, we now know that there's either more or less than 9, depending on how you define "planet." I don't care about definitions. What matters to me is to raise awareness of Pluto's sibling worlds.
© 2015 Ellen
hamjams on October 09, 2019:
Helo im hamjams butiful verygood sait owlcation.com nasa uranus Butiful photo
Milkbutcher on July 13, 2019:
Thank you for this great research! I wish I found it a year ago when I was hunting true color images myself for an art project, but it seems I was pretty spot on!
Also THANK YOU for including Ceres. Her denigration for over two centuries has been enough. If Pluto is a noteworthy part of our system’s family then so is she :)
james mwangih on February 02, 2019:
Tommy on January 31, 2019:
Thanks for your hard work! Very beautiful images and a really cool project to tackle
Onica on October 16, 2018:
What a wow.... I can't believe it.... tjoo
Art Donovan on October 09, 2018:
Really excellent post, Helen. Thank you for taking the time to do this. Comprehensive, unique and enjoyable! Best Wishes :)
ollie on September 26, 2018:
David weyama on September 19, 2018:
hellen thanks for informing me about planets,am now fully of it.
Heliochromo on July 12, 2018:
Nice presentation. It's a little surprising to see science so far behind in getting old color misconceptions corrected for a few of these.
You will likely find an improved "natural color" image of Venus taken from Messenger (2007) because it used red, green, and blue filters. The Mariner image you show used orange and UV filters only, as I understand. The UV filter enhances cloud structure but it is harder to use it for natural color rendering.
[More at the Planetary Soc.: http://www.planetary.org/blogs/emily-lakdawalla/20...]
There is another "planet" not shown that has a very long history of major color distortion... that bright thing that comes up every day (yep, the Sun). It ain't yeller! Grab a drink and you may enjoy reading the following zany article:
Elisa on July 10, 2018:
I like all the information about all the planet's
IwuzzaFool4NASA on May 31, 2018:
Its all fake. Mars Rovers are not on Mars they are actually still here on Earth in a place called Devon Island, Canada. I didn't believe this was true, not 1 bit till I just LOOK INTO IT for myself. The more I dug deep to find out the truth the more disappointed I got cause the evidence that shows the Rovers are still here on Earth out weigh any evidence that there on Mars. The one that got me sick to my stomach is when one of the rover was no longer working due to the Solar panels being covered in so much Mars dust that the rover could charge up any power. But then all of a sudden the solar panels were squeeky clean and NASA says it was wind that cleaned off the dust. C'mon now here on Earth if dust builds upon a window of a car I don't care how strong the winds are they are not going to blow it off squeeky clean unless it was rained on or someone cleaned it themselves. I FELT SO BETRAYED BY NASA. I didn't want to believe NASA would expect any humans to buy this simple explanation, but they do and they really don't care.
Isreal on May 30, 2018:
I was not interested but now I am
Nobody else vote on May 21, 2018:
It has 1337 people
Don't on February 22, 2018:
Keke on February 03, 2018:
I’ve never been so interested in other planets but now I want to learn more about them
obama on May 07, 2017:
cute9 on February 03, 2017:
i never learn some much about planet.
Frances Spiegel on October 13, 2016:
Wow! What an amazing article. I really enjoyed it. Thank you for so much hard work.
farmloft from Michigan on December 31, 2015:
Great hub. Your portrait is outstanding!
Maggie Griess from Ontario, Canada on October 13, 2015:
I have always been interested in the planets. Thank you for the color corrected versions. I am amazed there are two other blue-hued ones, so I would find Uranus and Neptune to be very interesting though I can't believe how fast those clouds travel on Neptune. My goodness, 1300 mph/2100 kph...mind boggling..and the gases...not so nice!
Kristen Howe from Northeast Ohio on August 18, 2015:
Ellen, this was a fantastic hub. Real useful and interesting to know about our planets with those beautiful photos! Voted up!
Ellen (author) from California on August 12, 2015:
Oh, goodness, I hadn't realized! Thank you very much.
Jack Lee from Yorktown NY on August 12, 2015:
Congratulations on an excellent hub, well deserved.